Re: Leslie Aiello's review of Cunnane's Survival of the Fattest


"Marc Verhaegen" <fa204466@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:44d5df9d$0$32428$ba620e4c@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Aiello should at least know
that AAT has nothing to do with apiths, but everything with shoreline
dispersals of Homo http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AAT It's not difficult
to
falsify non-existing hypotheses. Very unscientific attitude IMO.

Why should she or anyone else know that.? Oh right...
she is automatically supposed to elevate your farrago
to number one status and ignore all the other AATs
that are scampering around all over the place. Since
your take is no better argued than anyone else's why
is she conmstrained to do that? Oh silly me....by
mounting this club-footed dodge and weave you don't
have to actually deal with the critique....As an exercise
in sly cunning this leaves something to be desired, IMHO....

Rick Wagler


.