Re: Man-eaters

claudiusdenk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Lee Olsen wrote:
claudiusdenk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Lee Olsen wrote:
claudiusd...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Lee Olsen wrote:

They are only up in the trees when predators are in the immediate
vicinity, dimwit.

How stupid can you get? What if the predator decides not to leave?
Lucy then will come down and beat him up?

What a plainly inane question. I suppose in those instances the apith
in question would be out of luck.

Do you ever tire of making retractions? If they couldn't guard one, it
is obvious they couldn't guard any.

Why don't you step us through the logic that brought you to this
conclusion. If nothing else it should be good for a few laughs.

You really are insane. What makes the "apith in question would be out
of luck." any different from any other apith?

Uh . . . ?

Asks the loon who claims apiths were guarding gardens.







I can't figure out what your point is. Assuming you have one.

Niccolo Caldararo: "You really need to do some reading (and I've said
this before). It is embarrassing to you (or should be) for you to
continually make statements which most of us know are unsupported by
the data."

Who is Niccolo Caldararo? Why would anybody care about his opinion,
dimwit.

Who the hell is Claudius Jim Denk McGinn, other than an alias for
someone too embarassed to use his real name? Coward. But then again, if
I posted the lunatic drivel you did, I would change my name also.


No response.

Nothing to respond to....


Why would you quote the opinion of somebody that has no expertise in
this field?

No response.

Nothing to respond to...

Because you have no dispute with anything I'm saying. Admit it.


You are not saying anything, you are imagining you are saying
something.






Obviously he has a lot more expertise than you do.....
Message-ID: <1165825208.180342.263860@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Jim McGinn: "Much of the existing evidence is consistent with
gardens/groves, etc.
Hominid fossils tend to be found in association with trees and water
nearby. And hominid food preference are consistent with such."

Have you been mentally ill long?



Niccolo Caldararo is a guy who can see through an illiterate buffoon
like you.

We're suppose to take your word on this? Fat chance that.

Says the loon imagining apiths guarded gardens.



You might try going to the library for the first time in your life and
check out a book called BONES by Lew Binford.

Read it. It's conclusions are dimwitted.

Hearing voices again?

Feel free to relay to us the brilliant insights that you, supposedly,
gleened from your reading of this book.

No response.

You can't read? He wrote the book once, how many people have to write
something before you get it?

Uh . . . get what?

His observations on predators hunting at night.

What about them?

Jim McGinn: "Do you believe, like Paul, that
early hominids were incapable of seeing at night?"

Your imagination is working overtime, did someone say "incapable"?
Where? Still hearing voices? Leopards and hyenas see better than
apiths at night, that's why apiths get killed guarding gardens at
night.

Jim McGinn: "what purpose do the stone weapons (spears, bow and
arrow) serve that show up in the fossil record starting about 2.5
mya?"

Evidence? Citation?

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Man-eaters
    ... vicinity, dimwit. ... Asks the loon who claims apiths were guarding gardens. ... Jim McGinn: "Much of the existing evidence is consistent with ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: Man-eaters
    ... vicinity, dimwit. ... Says the loon imagining apiths guarded gardens. ... cheetah-like cat" Current Biology, Vol. 15, August 9, 2005. ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: Man-eaters
    ... vicinity, dimwit. ... Says the loon imagining apiths guarded gardens. ... cheetah-like cat" Current Biology, Vol. 15, August 9, 2005. ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: Man-eaters
    ... The trauma caused by these arrows may be a clue in the scholarly ... of whether warfare existed in the centuries before recorded history, ... Asks the loon who claims apiths were guarding gardens. ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)