Re: Jane Goodall notes

On Mar 13, 10:38 am, claudiusd...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
On Mar 11, 7:31 pm, "caldervang...@xxxxxxxxx"

<caldervang...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Saw Jane Goodall speak last Saturday night in Washington DC to a group
of educators, mostly about her program called Roots and Shoots.

I find her to be sweet, humble, smart.  A great lady & all women
scientists owe her some gratitude.

Her speech was grand.  Impassioned.  Entertaining.  Touching.
Factual.  It is probably somewhat of a "canned" speech, but so what?
I had not heard it yet....

I took notes.  I only have one line that is a direct quote, but here
goes:

Her mother was with her in the first 4 months of her work in Gombi, in
1960.  Louis Leakey helped get her started, and the both of them were
considered "crazy" at the time to send a woman off into the forest on
her own.

she saw chimps buiding nests in groups and on their own.

Dinosaurs and birds build nests.  So this is no great revelation.

I agree. However, compare and contrast that with gorilla nest
building....


She (of
course... all of us in sap know this) saw chimps using tools....

Lots of animals use tools in one respect or another.  It's silly to
suggest that chimpanzee tool usage tells us anything about how chimps
evolved in to humans.

I don't quite follow your reasoning here. Meanwhile, humans did not
evolve from chimps. We evolved from a common ancestor. Small words;
big difference.

Goodall gets credit for "shaking up" what you and Paul would call
"standard PA." This was no small feat, and she did it quite
scientifically. Clear and thorough field notes. Astute
observation.


even
stripping the leaves off twigs & to use that twig to fish out
termites.  This observation revolutionized our place in nature.... we
were at that time defined as humans at least in part by our ability to
use tools.

chimps have a whole series of gestures, and use them in the same
way(s) that humans do.

Chimps have their first child at about 13 years old, and then another
one every 5 or 6 years.  The bond between the mother and child gets
even stronger after the younger sibling is born.  A long childhood is
important to social learning -- like us -- and a young chimpanzee will
pay careful attention to to the behaviour of an adult IF he is
interested in the behaviour.

"our brain has had an explosion."  .... what caused our explosion?
She thinks it is
"this sophisticated language."

She's largely correct about this.  It's our ability to conceptualize
and understand the long-term value of resources so that we can work in
concert to maintain these resources and survive the dry season and its
very dramatic predatory/competitive factors.

Isn't there a long period, from 6 mya to 3 mya, when our presumptive
ancestors did not have a large brain? (although it could be argued
that we were smart without the added grey matter from 3 mya to the
present, but then what purpose does the added grey matter have?). I
guess what i don't understand, have never understood about, your
scenario, is the interaction between climate change, brain growth and
the known fossil record. Do all these factors actually add up?
regards
calder


and that we
communicate about things that are not present.
learn about things of the past
(now with writing)
plan way ahead
and can have a discussion with 10 people around a table and make sense
of it.

Well stated.  Yes.  All of these abilities emerged because of communal
selection.



J.G. then talked about when the forests disappear, deserts
appear.....  ice disappearing... (ask any Eskimo)....

Vague.  What mattered was the dry season.





in 1986, first Conservation Conference in Chicago (about chimps) ...
Congo basin threatened...

Gombi surrounded by cleared land.... the bush meat COMMERCIAL trade is
very harmful to chimps.

And then she talked a lot about her Roots and Shoots program.

regards
calder- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Jane Goodall notes
    ... scientists owe her some gratitude. ... evolved in to humans. ... Isn't there a long period, from 6 mya to 3 mya, when our presumptive ... but then what purpose does the added grey matter have?). ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: Australopithecus afarensis vs. chimps
    ... Australopithecus afarensis by John Gurche. ... much as modern humans, but their hands are *much* stronger than human hands. ... KWing doesn't contradict tool use & manufacture, see chimps. ... Why in Africa? ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: Humans, chimps, wheat and frogs
    ... are chromosomal rearrangements like inversions. ... aberrant chromosome. ... chimps do not produce viable hybrids, ... therefore show that humans and chimps are further apart in it than any ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: A critique of the BBC aquatic ape programme and the transcript.
    ... > all chimps. ... > isn't part of the niche of all humans. ... > a reasonable hypothesis that the trait is related to arboreality. ... analogues *of limited levels of aquaticism* of naked mammals does not ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Early humans and chimps may have interbred to create hybrid man
    ... Early humans and chimps may have interbred to create hybrid man ... evidence for hybridisation through interbreeding. ... history across the genomes of humans and chimps. ...
    (soc.culture.indian)