Re: Diverting attention from the real issues of hominid evolution

On Apr 12, 7:34 pm, "Makouli" <m...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
<claudiusd...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:961f708e-98f1-467d-9b62-431c9544dc23@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On Apr 12, 5:24 am, "Makouli" <m...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:





<claudiusd...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:864b91ef-8cb3-4f29-bb82-07dea794f74c@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On Apr 11, 7:40 pm, Marc Verhaegen <m_verhae...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

SF:

Almost all species drink water.

Sigh. Do chimps dive? Can they hold their breath for 5 minutes? Do they
have large brains? Do they have small mouths? SC fat? Are they naked?
This is rather obvious anecdotal nonsense. Yet it is the strongest
evidence of AAT.

Really? I mean I'll agree that it's the strongest evidence
but since it's non-evidence that really adds up to no
evidence at all --which is what the AAR has going for it.

Uh, okay.

Tell me, world's greatest living evolutionary theorist, how
does a chimp having a relatively (there's a loaded term)
large mouth add up to an aquatic past for humans?

I give up.  Why?



Further, since we're talking about chimps and you
were earlier going on and on about where they live,
what do you make of this?

Of what?



http://tinyurl.com/44ecge

You must have missed it the first time, eh? Or
were you just ignoring contradictory evidence --

How so?

like the good scientist you are. And there's a
little nugget here for Marco as well. It seems these
savanna chimps use a shallow pool as a home base
from which they make regular forays into the surrounding
countryside. No doubt he'll be adding it to his other
"evidence" above.

Just think think how much more interesting this behavior might be if
you actually had a point.

Just think how readable these posts would be
if you were smart enough to avoid screwing up
the attributes.  Maybe you should stop picking
your nose long enough to figure out how google
groups works, eh? The point being, if you were
smart enough to click on the link, is that chimps
are living where you said they don't.

specifically?


 That's a
savanna, Dimmy, and it's not short grass prairie.

Okay.

Should I slow down a bit so you can follow?

If you think it will help. In the meantime keep in mind that the rest
of us don't have direct access to your imagination.

.

Relevant Pages