Re: Anatase present in many Ancient artifacts as well


"Tom McDonald" <tmcdonald2672@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:foN8e.9932$c42.1613@xxxxxxxxxxx
> I.E_Johansson wrote:
>> Alaca,
>> if you didn't know it, which you obviously don't the pens which were used
>> to
>> write and draw lines in Medieval Age more than once were placed back in
>> pottery-vessels after being used.
>>
>> Apart from that the Anatase present in pottery from Ancient to Medieval
>> Age
>> has been presented to be in same range and forms as on VM.
>> If you don't see the significance, well others do.
>
> Johansson,
>
> In that case, *you* have to explain the preferential uptake of anatase
> from the pottery vessels. It seems that none of the other, more major
> constituents of the clay used to make the pottery was similarly taken up
> by the pen. Why not?

Regardles of the clay and with due respect Tom, I accept it is easy to
simply bodyslam Ms Johansson. My first thought, however, was WRT the
thousands of historical documents that do not test positive to the "Anatase
present in pottery from Ancient to Medieval Age". Johansson, 2005.
(notwithstanding the positive sample to only parts of the document!)

Oh My God! (in squealing Valley Girl shriek) Is only the VM authentic and
the rest
fakes?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

Dave
Philosopher Authorised
---------------
The only good reed is a Renforz
---------------




.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Anatase present in many Ancient artifacts as well
    ... which you obviously don't the pens which were used to write and draw lines in Medieval Age more than once were placed back in ... Apart from that the Anatase present in pottery from Ancient to Medieval Age ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Anatase present in many Ancient artifacts as well
    ... >> if you didn't know it, which you obviously don't the pens which were used to ... >> Apart from that the Anatase present in pottery from Ancient to Medieval Age ... Doug Weller -- exorcise the demon to reply ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Anatase present in many Ancient artifacts as well
    ... > write and draw lines in Medieval Age more than once were placed back ... So pottery leachates are the source of the 20th century Anatase. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: more about Range Creek
    ... Inger E Johansson wrote: ... >>found something in the picture of the pottery pieces that you ... > don't know what so specific I gather it has been many pottery pieces found ...
    (sci.archaeology)
Loading