Re: Scholars and Theory of Science former Re: The Vinland Map's Ink

"Ken Towe" <ken.towe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1114519113.431277.150810@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Will you please answer the questions that have been raised by your own
> comments?
>
> (1) One would need an electron microscope to see your natural anatase
> clearly for accurate comparison with that on the Vinland Map. Except
> for the kaolin anatase, NONE of the material you describe is small
> enough to have any relationship to the anatase seen on the Vinland Map.
> Therefore, where has any of your natural anatase been described in
> detail so that we (and you, yourself) can be sure that it is like that
> seen on the Vinland Map?
>
> (2) If we see natural anatase in the ink, why don't we also see the
> other mineral sands or clays too? How is that possible? Doesn't it seem
> strange that you can see the anatase but not the sand that is sprinkled
> on the ink with it?
>
> (3) Can you help us by pointing, specifically, to a few other medieval
> documents that have sand (any kind) remaining on them? If this was a
> common menthod of drying ink, where are the other documents?
>
> Any scholar, any theory of science, requires support (data) consistent
> with the theory. You have not provided any answers that even moderately
> support your natural anatase theory. If you are unwilling to do so why
> should anyone believe you? How about some answers? That's the
> scholarly, scientifc way, don't you agree?

Don't expect straight answers or scientific substance. Expect a completely
new thread rambling off at a tangent.

Alan

--
Alan Crozier
Lund
Sweden


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: V.M. last word
    ... weak spot. ... One would need an electron microscope to see your natural anatase ... If we see natural anatase in your medieval ink, ... it seem strange that you can see the anatase but not the sand that is ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Scholars and Theory of Science former Re: The Vinland Maps Ink
    ... One would need an electron microscope to see your natural anatase ... enough to have any relationship to the anatase seen on the Vinland Map. ... If we see natural anatase in the ink, why don't we also see the ... strange that you can see the anatase but not the sand that is sprinkled ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: The Vinland Map Find Or Fraud?
    ... manufactured in 1400's from sand-kaolin to sand for drying ink. ... we call Vinland map today or not. ... What's lacked in McCrones study is a good comparing test of Scandinavian, ...
    (sci.archaeology)