Re: The Minoan origin of the Phaistos disc



Why choosing as the title of this thread "The Minoan origin of the
Phaistos Disk" ?
Do you seriously believe that it enhances the credibility of your
"Calendaric Solution" ????
On the CONTRARY !
Because there are LOTS of ARGUMENTS showing that the Phaistos Disk is
NOT Minoan :
1)- Following a search made in the 1920ies (but not published), its
clay IS NOT CRETAN
2)- ItsHieroglyphs are NOT similar to the Cretan Hieroglyphs : VERY
FREQUENT CretanHieroglyohs like the "double axe", the "consecration
horns", etc. are MISSING. When there is a correspondent, its DESIGN is
VERY DIFFERENT : the "ship" has not a "round hull" like the Cretan
ships -- the costume of the "waman" is Ugaritian, not really Cretan --
the "ram" is represented in profile instead of in front -- etc.
3)- Some of the Phaistos Disk's signs point to a NON-CRETAN culture :
the "crested head" , the "round shield" have their equivalent in the
"Sea Peoples" representations, NOT IN CRETE.
4)- The Disk has been printed with stamps IN RELIEF. ALL the CRETAN
seals are IN HOLLOW.
5)- In spite of intensive diggings in Crete, NO OTHER DISK has been
found there...

grapheus

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Is the Phaistos Disk Minoan?
    ... I see no need to talk about lies like "The Phaistos Disk has been ... Therefore, it "must" be Minoan". ... who strongly wants the Phaistos Disk not to be Proto-Ionian (I ... and Egyptian scarabs in Crete. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Is the Phaistos Disk Minoan?
    ... > for a greek background for the Phaistos Disk. ... > up to now I haven't given a proof for a Minoan origin. ... >> but to be Minoan, has written a lengthy post on the subjet. ... COMING from the same FOREIGN CULTURE. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Is the Phaistos Disk Minoan?
    ... > for a greek background for the Phaistos Disk. ... > up to now I haven't given a proof for a Minoan origin. ... >> but to be Minoan, has written a lengthy post on the subjet. ... COMING from the same FOREIGN CULTURE. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Is the Phaistos Disk Minoan?
    ... > for a greek background for the Phaistos Disk. ... > up to now I haven't given a proof for a Minoan origin. ... >> but to be Minoan, has written a lengthy post on the subjet. ... COMING from the same FOREIGN CULTURE. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Epimenidis
    ... It is the decipherment of the inscription on the famous ... Phaistos Disk of Crete, which is in question. ... Through my website you'll become acquainted with my method of ...
    (sci.crypt)