Re: The Vinland Map's Ink

On 2 May 2005 21:19:17 GMT, Philip Deitiker <Nopdeitik@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

>In sci.archaeology, Ken Towe created a message ID
>news:1115045326.061789.55370@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx:
>
>> I would not disagree at all. You have expressed this very
>well, both
>> here and in your following post. I suspect Mr. Stevens will
>be too busy
>> with his many other projects to agree or disagree with you.
>After all,
>> if he did so he would then have taken an actual position on
>something,
>> and he doesn't seem willing to do that.
>
>There you go. And with that we need to move on from this
>VM map.
>
>Summary-
> The mdm refuses to accept any evidence of fraud concerning
>articles that supports broader familiarity of Vinland in 15th
>century as fraudulent no matter what the evidence.
> Eric refuses to take a position, while admitting there is no
>evidence that it was a 15th century map,

Read for context. I have never said that.

> ... he refuses to close
>the door on the fact that it was authentic to a later period,
>possibly the bristol period.
>
>Of course there are a gazillion other archaeological topics
>worth discussion, but this seems to be the obsession of a few.
>Realizing this is an area of your expertise but this is more
>about antiquity and history than it is about archaeology.
>




Eric Stevens

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Vinland Maps Ink
    ... > with his many other projects to agree or disagree with you. ... The mdm refuses to accept any evidence of fraud concerning ... Eric refuses to take a position, ... Of course there are a gazillion other archaeological topics ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Stevens III: No further prosecutions
    ... The no inquiry due to prosecutions red herring has now gone. ... prosecutions will be brought against any individual following Lord Stevens ... The PPS, when considering the available evidence in Stevens III, ... test for prosecution must be applied and the Director of Public Prosecutions ...
    (soc.culture.irish)
  • Re: Kaif to play in XI
    ... > You may well disagree with Chappell's opinion about Ganguly's present ... > and future worth (hypothetically - I have no more evidence than you ... > not tell the selectors what his opinion is? ... > The evidence that the Gangulites are producing seems to ...
    (rec.sport.cricket)
  • Re: The Icelandic coconut
    ... > with Stevens. ... >> is a first class crackpot, and no amount of logic or fact ... >> from his crackpot theory of the moment. ... alternative hypothesis no matter how much evidence and logic is stacked up ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Stevens III: No further prosecutions
    ... prosecutions will be brought against any individual following Lord Stevens ... The PPS, when considering the available evidence in Stevens III, ... test for prosecution must be applied and the Director of Public Prosecutions ...
    (soc.culture.irish)
Loading