Re: Some of the Logic of KRS discussion

On Fri, 10 Jun 2005 01:23:28 GMT, Philip Deitiker
<Donevenask@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

>Eric Stevens <eric.stevens@xxxxxxxxx> says in
>news:p6kha1t9fmuk6bhsr536sttfoaf8kmmsv0@xxxxxxx:
>
>> On Fri, 10 Jun 2005 00:12:13 +0200, "Alaca" <P.Alaca@xxxxxxxx>
>> wrote:
>>
>>>Eric Stevens wrote: 6pcha1l78dibosdibc17klkga5ein26aau@xxxxxxx,
>>>> Philip Deitiker wrote:
>>>
>>>>> Rather that argue around in circles with people who want to
>>>>> debate trivia rather than what constitutes a good argument I
>>>>> have decided to set this aside.
>>>>
>>>> It's been pretty obvious that this is all you have wanted to
>>>> do from the moment you first heard of the KRS.
>>>
>>>What, starting a clean thread?
>>
>> Set the KRS aside.
>>
>> He's been agin it from the very first moment he heard of it. He
>> arrived in this newsgroup labelling anyone who didn't want to
>> reject it outright as 'KOOKS' or hyperdiffusionists.
>
>I was neutral to the KRS. I was calling people kooks because of the
>style of their proofs for its authenticity. For example, proclaiming
>that a deceased C.1362 organization carved the stone is a kooky idea.

That wasn't even suggested until probably a year later.
>
>> Go back through the threads and you will find a consistent
>> pattern of bias and arguing from ignorance. What he calls
>> 'trivia' are the facts of the matter.
>
>Give me a break, they are bull***. You don't prove that the sun
>exists by looking at the reflections of light off planets of distance
>suns.

I suppose you consider gravitational microlensing equally KOOKY.
>
>> You watch him now build a
>> fact-free argument against the KRS based on irrelevancies and
>> what people haven't said.
>
>You can't seem to answer basic quetion and yet you claim to have the
>firmest understanding of the facts.

Of course I can't answer some of the more basic questions. Nobody can.
All I claim about my knowledge of the facts is that it is firmer than
yours.

>
>1. Where did the stone core come from?
>2. Who and where was it carved?
>By who I mean what people.
>
>Start there.




Eric Stevens

.