Re: Sorry! The Phaistos disc.


>> My opinion is, that my 22 stem-forms are real, and that they reveal an
>> integrated system, consisting of elements of two signs.
>
>Of course, it's real. But is its meaning the one you think ?.. That is
>the question !..

I believe, that the constructor of the disc was actually working with
elements of two, and not the individual sign. All statistical
experiments, you carry on, proves so.
>
>> 2) When you succssed in placing a reasonable 8 months linear calendar
>> into this material, just by inserting one initial sign on both sides,
>> then this discovery is to be taken seriously in a case like this one,
>> it cannot just be rejected.
>
>This is the flaw in your demonstration : in order to get something
>which looks "reasonable", you have to ARBITRARILY add two "signs". In
>other words, you are entering into a NON-SCIENTIFIC reasoning : "the
>figure doesn't fit with the conclusion I want to reach ?.. I change
>the figure and keep the conclusion" !!!
>And this BIAS is increased a lot more with the taking in consideration
>of your "Reduced stems" !...
>A real SCIENTIFIC mind would do the contrary : "The figure doesn't fit
>with my hypothesis ?.. I reject the hypothesis" !... (Mainly when
>another one fits !)...
>
>grapheus
>
Not more arbitrarily or non-scientific than adding eka-boron to the
periodical table, later confirmed as a real matter.
Remember the two majuscles are not added, they exist, I am only
promoting them to real signs.
http://home.gvdnet.dk/~hagen/256.htm

Hagen
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Sorry! The Phaistos disc.
    ... consisting of elements of two signs. ... But is its meaning the one you think ?.. ... The statistics can be ... >>figure doesn't fit with the conclusion I want to reach ?.. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Spool size/file size Word 2000
    ... Many thanks Suzanne, I suppose it's something we will have to live with. ... The document is actually only 16 pages in total, consisting of 63 ... finished file would not fit on a CD! ... Mike H ...
    (microsoft.public.word.newusers)
Loading