Re: Sorry! The Phaistos disc.



O.H. wrote:
> >> My opinion is, that my 22 stem-forms are real, and that they reveal an
> >> integrated system, consisting of elements of two signs.
> >
> >Of course, it's real. But is its meaning the one you think ?.. That is
> >the question !..
>
> I believe, that the constructor of the disc was actually working with
> elements of two, and not the individual sign. All statistical
> experiments, you carry on, proves so.

But the decipherment proves the contrary !.. The statistics can be
explained by the characteristics of the couple "Greek language+ Type of
script". (See examples in my preceding post).

> >
> >> 2) When you succssed in placing a reasonable 8 months linear calendar
> >> into this material, just by inserting one initial sign on both sides,
> >> then this discovery is to be taken seriously in a case like this one,
> >> it cannot just be rejected.
> >
> >This is the flaw in your demonstration : in order to get something
> >which looks "reasonable", you have to ARBITRARILY add two "signs". In
> >other words, you are entering into a NON-SCIENTIFIC reasoning : "the
> >figure doesn't fit with the conclusion I want to reach ?.. I change
> >the figure and keep the conclusion" !!!
> >And this BIAS is increased a lot more with the taking in consideration
> >of your "Reduced stems" !...
> >A real SCIENTIFIC mind would do the contrary : "The figure doesn't fit
> >with my hypothesis ?.. I reject the hypothesis" !... (Mainly when
> >another one fits !)...
> >
> >grapheus
> >
> Not more arbitrarily or non-scientific than adding eka-boron to the
> periodical table, later confirmed as a real matter.
> Remember the two majuscles are not added, they exist, I am only
> promoting them to real signs.

YES! And this is an "ad hoc" decision !...
What is the problem...

grapheus

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Deseasonalization and detrending of Keeling curve
    ... fit with a linear gain factor. ... The "fit" is based on a stiff spline ... MODEL STATISTICS AND EQUATION FOR THE CURRENT EQUATION (DETAILS ... Standard Error of the Mean =Standard Dev/ .148530E-01 ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: Regression significance conundrum
    ... > is a good linear correlation between the two variables. ... > that a quadratic fit does not confer significant additional benefit? ... If you do the statistics properly, then you probably won't have any ... referees) you thought there was some slight curvature. ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: Mystery of Innes Bogus Statistics Solved
    ... GM Adorjan's statistics all screwed up, ... Adorjan himself was apparently working with bogus, ... The meaning should flow *from* ... not working against it to help any pet theory. ...
    (rec.games.chess.misc)
  • Re: Mystery of Innes Bogus Statistics Solved
    ... GM Adorjan's statistics all screwed up, ... Adorjan himself was apparently working with bogus, ... The meaning should flow *from* ... not working against it to help any pet theory. ...
    (rec.games.chess.misc)
  • Re: low blank high
    ... what is the usual word that would fit in between ... The mathematical definition of the "median" value ... I dispute that "average" has a specific meaning in statistics, ...
    (alt.usage.english)