Re: VM reading lesson


"Tom McDonald" <tmcdonald2672@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:j8UCe.10873$1Y1.7819@xxxxxxxxxxx
> IEJ wrote:
>> "maison.mousse" <maison.mousse@xxxxxxxxxx> skrev i meddelandet
>> news:42dbeabc$0$22291$8fcfb975@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>>
>>>IEJ a écrit dans le message ...
>>>
>>>>Doug,
>>>>lousier homework then that made by Towe exists, but not many has made so
>>>>many major mistakes as he has done from a position equal or above his.
>>>>His studies and works in the VM question doesn't show the quality,
>>>
>>>precision
>>>
>>>>and correct argumentation as he is known to present.
>>>>
>>>>Inger E
>>>>
>>>
>>>Nothing in Towe's work is up to date he has not tested
>>>or as far as known even seen the map.
>>>He can only rely on the test run by the various laboratories. The
>>>conclusions of these various analysis
>>>was that the map as far as can be determined is genuine. Unless further
>>>test can be done is labs just as
>>>well equipped and by those just as qualified , the results
>>>stand.
>>>JL
>>
>>
>> And that's what we wait for the Danes who performed such tests to present
>> their verdict on.
>
> And yet, she has no trouble jumping to conclusions before the fact.
>
>> Please observe that they doesn't seem to have any of Towe's thoughts
>> regarding the ink.
>
> Does anyone know if the Danes were planning to investigate the ink?
>
>> For them as they presented their halfway short
>> information it seems to be all about the parchment. Is the parchment same
>> type, not only age, as the Tartar documents, which type of parchment has
>> been used, where was that parchment 'made' etc.
>
> Interesting questions. I will wait patiently for the Danes to *FINISH*
> their work.
>
>> The ink problem is no more
>> since it's shown that a 1437 formula, observe that it wasn't Olin that
>> found
>> that one, gives exact same ink as on VM anatase size included.
>
> Anyone know where this wonder of scientific work can be investigated? Or
> is this one of Inger's hold-back cards. (IOW, fantasy.)
>
>> This means
>> that anyone putting forward VM as being forged must at least have an idea
>> how the proposed forger between the time he is supposed to have forged it
>> and last years could be the only one having had knowledge of and access
>> to
>> that formula......
>
> And that formula is? Including the source of the anatase, size of the
> particles, and other ingredients?

As is normally the case, this is simply pure fantasy on Inger's part.

>
> --
> Tom McDonald
> http://ahwhatdoiknow.blogspot.com/

Steve
--
The above posting is neither a legal opinion nor legal advice,
because we do not have an attorney-client relationship, and
should not be construed as either. This posting does not
represent the opinion of my employer, but is merely my personal
view. To reply, delete _spamout_ and replace with the numeral 3


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Vineland
    ... >>analysis which yielded a date for the ink of 1916 onwards. ... strongly adheres via absorption to the parchment and an apparently overlaid ... The above posting is neither a legal opinion nor legal advice, ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • VM parchment
    ... Eumenes, king of Pergamus, introduced the use of Parchment properly ... When ink(Gallotannate ink) is applied to "fresh" parchment the ink will not ... dye will disappear. ... the writing will still be black, but no longer blue-black [if blue dye was ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: VM reading lesson
    ... > regarding the ink. ... > information it seems to be all about the parchment. ... resulted in the 20th century anatase turning up on the Vinland Map. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: The Vinland Maps Ink
    ... He accepts that the ink ... >>already poorly visible ink and the intervening parchment in a bleaching ... The process adds modern anatase from the coating of special ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Vineland
    ... I understand that it is generally accepted that the parchment comes ... >am unclouding the issue by arguing that the map lacks proper ... >> I think not, since Eric's point was that saying that the ink ... >a wider range if the history of anastase is incomplete. ...
    (sci.archaeology)