Re: Atlantis = The Sea People?

On 28 Dec 2005 07:28:29 -0800, in sci.archaeology, dhobraasch wrote:

>On 27 Dec 2005 02:49:04 -0800, in sci.archaeology, dhobraasch wrote:
>
>
>> Doug Founded is not the correct word to used. Sumer and Egypt developed, they eren't 'founded'.For Egypt, look here:http://www.touregypt.net/ebph5.htm
>No references I admit, but plenty of detail that can be checked. No
>'founding there', and certainly no evidence of outsiders coming in at
>3000
>BC. Also
>http://africanhistory.about.com/od/egyptology/a/PreDynasticEgpt.htm
>Gradual development is shown there, not something suddenly happening
>from outside. <<
>
>Agree, the comon view

No, that's not a view, that's what the archaeology shows.

>
>>Doug And you have been asked for your source for 20000 dolmen in Palestine and details about how many Palestinian dolmen fit into your argument. They vary, some are clearly related with certain settlements, and as I have told you before: "my copy of Dolmens for the Dead, Megalith Building through the World, by Roger Joussaume, has pictures of Dolmen from 'Palestine' in it that are distinctively different from those in NW Europe, it is clearly not well established that they are 'identical'
>
>Indeed it is not well established, but so far it COULD be ´
>ìdentical, or better to say mythically related ?

It isn't established at all, in fact it is clear that some are distinctly
different.

>
>> Unless you are a follower of Yair Davidiy, of course, who does make this claim. "<
>
>Sorry so far I never heard of Yair Davidiy

Good, you haven't missed anything.
>
>>Doug Megaliths (my guess is you aren't really talking about only dolmen) are found all over the world, some very old, some pretty recent. But they differ in age, design, associated artefacts and burial types, etc. And there are vast areas where there are none also.<<
>
>Agree, little is known, but Megaliths covers a time of 4000 years. Why
>? All coincidental ?

I don't know what you mean by this. Humans have been building dolmens for
7000 years -- up to modern times (20th century in Malagasy). Rocks are
very useful.

>
>
>>DB. Problem II: The Mediterranean dolmen are about 1000 years younger than the Northern Megaliths. Data pointing to an European Megalithic Culture ? <
>
>> Doug .No, clearly not as there is so little in common.
>What range covers the term so LITTLE ? Why not to say :" It is unknown
>or unbelievable!"

Because those are opinions. The fact is that there are great differences.

>
>>Doug It really is time for you to start talking about detail. I've seen your 20000 dolmen figure several times and you never give any detail. And you don't appear to know anything about the development of civilization in Egypt.<<
>I
>Well let us talk about detail, but I am not so much interestetd in well
>established mainstream data. May be you are better informed. If so
>then let me know:.
>
>1:) WHO built the dolmen in Palestine ?

Which ones? They weren't all built at the same time or by the same people.

>2.) What is the mythical meaning of he milk goddess Hathor?
>3.) What is mythical meaning of the spiral at the crown of Narmer ?
>(2,3, Narmer palette)
>
> To connect Altlantis and Sea People
>4.) What is the meaning of the double spiral at the capital of ionic
>columns ?( After Vitruv still the hair of a woman ?)
>
Stick with the archaeology, at least that's real. Trying to understand
ancient symbolism leads in too many possible directions, and in any case,
this is an archaeology newsgroup.

>and last not least the Pyramid texts
>(www.braasch-megalith.de/pyramid-text.html
>
>1168 >>My father ascends the sky among the gods who are in the sky;
>he stands at the Great Polar Region and learns the speech of the
>sun-folk (1174 he who is north of the waterway, the end of the sky)<<
>The meaning of the SUNFOLK to my experience asking Egyptologists is
>unkown.
>
>Dieter Braasch
>
>P.S. What is the mythical link between the ´boat burrial´ of Cheops
>and the Anglosaxon knight in SuttonHoo ?
>The answer may be in the pyramid texts. Agree may sound a litle bit
>strange to suppose that the mythical background of SuddenHoo might be
>expained with Egyptian text almost four millennia before..
>A matter to talk in detail.

Not here. You need to deal with the Dolmen here.

Doug
--
Doug Weller --
Doug & Helen's Dogs http://www.dougandhelen.com
A Director and Moderator of The Hall of Ma'at http://www.hallofmaat.com
Doug's Archaeology Site: http://www.ramtops.co.uk


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Vinland
    ... forward a site based on Seaver. ... Biologists writing within their field on biological aspects of archaeology ... Doug ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Atlantis = The Sea People?
    ... Sumer and Egypt developed, they eren't 'founded'.For Egypt, look here:http://www.touregypt.net/ebph5..htm ... > Doug .No, clearly not as there is so little in common. ... What is mythical meaning of the spiral at the crown of Narmer? ... 1168>>My father ascends the sky among the gods who are in the sky; ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Making sense of HLA (I)
    ... your presentations of archaeology with those of Doug Weller's. ... I've looked at Doug Wellers stuff, he could be Superman, but what ... Begin second level of quote ... 'This rock pile overhere is a chinese pile, this is a celtic pile, ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Jumping to Mehrgarh as at least a farming village if not a pre-Flood city
    ... any representations of mine about Hancock. ... the focus shifts to the millennia before Mehrgarh was founded. ... This is somewhat outside archaeology per se because it involves ... Let's be intellectually honest, Doug. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Cocaine in ancient Egypt?
    ... And why can't you answer a straight question? ... difficult or you don't actually have any reference. ... Doug Weller -- exorcise the demon to reply ... Doug's Archaeology Site: http://www.ramtops.co.uk ...
    (sci.archaeology)