Re: Questions


Inger E.(Norah) skrev:

"JerryT" <cgjt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1161711845.232578.51950@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Alan Crozier skrev:

"Eric Stevens" <eric.stevens@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:95rhh25862kqdcdtq7osm2uvu0ub71b5ri@xxxxxxxxxx
On Tue, 26 Sep 2006 06:43:51 GMT, "Inger E"
<inger_e.johansson@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:



snip


And Alan sent you ref to a work where this is mentioned.

Alan, is this correct? Have you cited a work which describes the
global sea level as being 15 meters above the present at some time in
the bronze age?

I haven't seen the work to which Inger refers so I don't know what the
authors say, if anything, about global sea level. Their report is about
"Recent sedimentary deposits and sediment chemistry" of Lake Vättern.
Inger cites it only in connection with the tilting of the lake which led
to the formation of the river Motala Ström ca. 5700 BC.

I don't understand why Inger seems so reluctant to quote a source to
back up her statement. She said it was in a pre-stage of her C-essay. I
have only the finished essay. That's from 1993. Surely some research has
been done since then?


Just for the record...

In their work mentioned up this thread
Lars Håkanson and Thorsten Ahl
do not discuss global sea level other
than when it had an impact on Lake Vättern,
and they certainly do not anywhere in it
mention or claim a bronze age global sea level
15 meter above or belowe anything. They do not
discuss global sea level at all.

JerryT

IEJ: For the record - There are numerous works, type we call 'arbetskopior'
in other word not printed to be edited in public but to different meetings
with specialists.
As it happened in 1993 I had direct contact with SGI(Statens Geotekniska
Insititute) in Linköping, not to mention that I in my direct surrounding at
that time had three of the best specialists including one at that time
working at the University, BUT I was told to use a lower grade in my C-essay
so it would be possible for anyone reading it to go finding the referred
work at a University or major Library elsewhere. Had anyone of you gone thru
the other geologic works or for that matter the archaeologic works I have in
my ref.list you would have had same information and different references for
that information given in the ref.works!!!!!

Among those I had helping me and pre-viewing my essay were one archaeologist
and two Ph.D in Geology.
The later I had had when I studied Geography to become a teacher. Here in
Sweden a teacher of Geography has to read a lot of Geology and I had had
those specialists when studying courses. One of them worked at the
University, one of them at the 'Lärarhögskolan'.

That said I would like to express my continued surprise to learn that you
Jerry, at least you, aren't familiar with those facts. There are numerous
lists with figures I thought most who tried to get hold of this information
here in Sweden at least could be able to read at a University Library who
ordered them for you!

Inger E

It would not be the first time you discredit other people by making up
things.

JT

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Questions
    ... And Alan sent you ref to a work where this is mentioned. ... authors say, if anything, about global sea level. ... Inger cites it only in connection with the tilting of the lake which led ... Sweden a teacher of Geography has to read a lot of Geology and I had had ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Questions
    ... And Alan sent you ref to a work where this is mentioned. ... I haven't seen the work to which Inger refers so I don't know what the ... authors say, if anything, about global sea level. ... Sweden a teacher of Geography has to read a lot of Geology and I had had ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Questions
    ... And Alan sent you ref to a work where this is mentioned. ... authors say, if anything, about global sea level. ... "Recent sedimentary deposits and sediment chemistry" of Lake Vättern. ... Inger cites it only in connection with the tilting of the lake which led ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Questions
    ... And Alan sent you ref to a work where this is mentioned. ... authors say, if anything, about global sea level. ... "Recent sedimentary deposits and sediment chemistry" of Lake Vättern. ... Inger cites it only in connection with the tilting of the lake which led ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Questions
    ... Type sediment into the title field, ... authors say, if anything, about global sea level. ... Inger cites it only in connection with the tilting of the lake which led ... And the Roman Age rising you refer to is only one out of many ...
    (sci.archaeology)
Loading