Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!




Eric Stevens wrote:

It might be a rhetorical question but you are changing the
subject. We started off with one person who may or may not
want to learn to read pesher.

That's not true. The post that started this thread reads:

"Science is based on the idea that one scientist can replicate
and confirm the work of another scientist. I publicly challenge
Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher
method" so that a qualified scholar can apply it the the
transfiguration passage in Mark Chapter 9 and independently
come up with the "hidden pesher meaning" of Jesus stripping
the Jewish High Priest naked and carrying out the atonement
ritual in his place."

In the english language, the phrase "So that a qualified scholar"
in the paragraph above means any qualified scholar, not one
particular qualified scholar.

Could it be that you are confusing this thread with some
other thread that started off with one person who may or
may not want to learn to "read pesher" using Thiering's method?

The fact remains that *nobody* can test Thiering's "pesher
method" to see whether they get the same results she does.
Only Thiering can work the method, and she has not revealed
enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results.
If she ever reveals that as-yet-secret information, *then*
we shall see whether anyone wishes to learn her method.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!
    ... Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher ... the phrase "So that a qualified scholar" ... enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!
    ... Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher ... the phrase "So that a qualified scholar" ... enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!
    ... Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher ... the phrase "So that a qualified scholar" ... enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!
    ... Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher ... the phrase "So that a qualified scholar" ... enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Barbara Thiering Refuted!
    ... Barbara Thiering or any of her followers to explain her "pesher ... the phrase "So that a qualified scholar" ... enough of the details for anyone else to replicate her results. ...
    (sci.archaeology)