Re: North America's Bronze Age?

Peter Alaca wrote:
johansson <1732johansson@xxxxxxxxx > wrote:

<joerevskelton@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> skrev i
diskussionsgruppsmeddelandet:DTbZh.15860$XU4.12397@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx


"johansson" <1732johansson@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:vfWYh.39643$E02.15919@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Digger <p.dunn1@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> skrev i
diskussionsgruppsmeddelandet:NTOYh.1411$s35.546@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"johansson" <1732johansson@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:ZzvYh.39548$E02.15801@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Digger <p.dunn1@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> skrev i

diskussionsgruppsmeddelandet:W%lYh.1174$N05.334@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

The word "bronze" is not mentioned anywhere in the article.

So why is the heading of this thread "North America's Bronze
Age" ?

A little misleading don't you think?

Only for fools who can't read the lines I wrote! Are you such?

Oh dear!
I read your heading and asked a very simple question. Maybe you
should get
a
better grasp of English before calling people "fools". Maybe then
you will
be a little easier to understand!!

The heading is written in correct English as intended.'

But only copper artifacts are mentioned in the North Amertica
articles, No Bronze.

Only fools like you can miss that a question needs background.
Background for question presented in the first article.
Please observe 'Bronze Age items' and not 'Bronze artifacts' or
'Bronze Age
artifacts'

No mention of Bronze in the North America articles.
Only Copper.

Wrong. I suppose you didn't even try to read about the Bolivian Bronze
casting?


Bolivia in North America?

Apart from which. There are as I told the group only two ways the
metallurgic technology needed could have come to for example the
Inca's knowledge:
* Local knowledge:
either learnt due to own local experience during an un-known time in
the past.
or
the 1100 AD Bronze cast and artifacts like bells etc, found in Bolivia
represent the first local experience of Bronze production.

* Diffusion:
either from other parts of America
or from the Vikings.

Vikings in Bolivia?


While it's impossible for you or other naysayers to use both a wall
against of Viking influence in America at the same time maintaining
your present view against North American Bronze melting in
Pre-Columbian Age due to finding of the Bolivian cast,
I seriously doubt that the Vikings were interested in Bronze
production ONLY outside Greenland, Iceland and Scandinavia.
Now since cast been found and forged Bronze artifacts found in South
and Central America definitely dated to Pre-Columbian Age, the
possibilities for why who and where narrows down even more.


For the later speaks all the alloys used by for example the Incas.
Alloys needing hot temperatures and fire to be 'learnt' and used.

Do you and the naysayers have problem reading from A via B to C?

When A and B are totally unrelated, getting to C is impossible.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Pot terminology?
    ... They are probably amongst my favourite artefacts of the Bronze ... age graves in Germany often show parts, or a whole set, of vessels used for ... probably used only for burials or burial related rituals. ... ceramics usually show only a few pieces of this thin walled and finely made ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Pretty Ugly, alright, and I thought it was pretty.
    ... "When are you going to have the Bronze age torques you made? ... apart from the lighter ones with incised designs ... or the berber (ex maria teresa silver coins)solid silver woven type? ...
    (rec.crafts.jewelry)
  • Re: North Americas Bronze Age?
    ... articles, No Bronze. ... Please observe 'Bronze Age items' and not 'Bronze artifacts' or ... Bolivia in North America? ... Now since cast been found and forged Bronze artifacts found in South ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Bronze Metalworking and the Bronze Age
    ... age of metal working with bronze before bronze metal working was ... replaced with iron in the Iron Age. ... The making of bronze is from the combination of tin and copper. ... big players controlling tin production and how much influence did these ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • SV: North Americas Bronze Age?
    ... So why is the heading of this thread "North America's Bronze Age"? ... But only copper artifacts are mentioned in the North Amertica articles, ... No mention of Bronze in the North America articles. ...
    (sci.archaeology)