Re: message to Tom McDonald re. cayennepepper


"Alan Crozier" <name1.name2@xxxxxxxxx> skrev i meddelandet
news:jspji.3576$ZA.1641@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
"Inger E" <inger no spam_e.johansson@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:a2pji.3571$ZA.1253@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"Tedd Jacobs" <tjacobs@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> skrev i meddelandet
news:f6l45b029p1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"Inger E" wrote...
I was in contact with the library where I read the article and
other
works
of the Prof. Due to it's limited open hours during July I can't go
there
until monday. The other library here in Gothenburg where the
journal in
question can be read will not open until 30th July.

so you'll, of course, give references to these articles. author,
title,
journal, etc.?

Done so earlier this week.

And to make it easier for Tedd to follow this debate, it's best to
repeat the reference to Hjelmqvist's article, which can be found here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Columbian_trans-oceanic_contact#Agriculture
(see note 4).

Hakon Hjelmqvist (1905-1999) was the Swedish pioneer of archaeobotany,
who was honoured shortly after his death by having the following
conference volume dedicated to him:
http://www.umu.se/archaeology/publikation/ae/viklund2002_eng.html

In other words, this is an unusually serious and authoritative and
well-documented claim, published in a peer-reviewed journal by a scholar
whose name is only ever spoken with reverence. I haven't read his
article on the alleged find of cayenne pepper in medieval Lund (I have
only one issue of that journal here at home, from 1991 -- it has an
article by him about garden plants in medieval Lund but no mention of
Capsicum), so I don't know what explanations he suggests for the
apparent presence of this Transatlantic plant in Precolumbian Europe.

Alan

Hi Alan,
nice to see you back from holiday and fit for next word-fight. The best work
of the Professor is in my opinion his
"Die älteste Geschichte der Kulturpflanzen in Schweden: The oldest history
of cultivated plants in Sweden , 1955 ISSN 0006-8195

in regards of Lund his article from the 'Hulegrävningen' in the excavation
report "Frön och frukter från det äldsta Lund" is interesting.

Inger E



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: message to Tom McDonald re. cayennepepper
    ... so you'll, of course, give references to these articles. ... And to make it easier for Tedd to follow this debate, ... article by him about garden plants in medieval Lund but no mention ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: any hydro peeps here?
    ... the hydroponics ... references to references that suggest it MAY BE true. ... Mitchell's work is going to be reviewed by the UK's FSA seemed to be a ... "The Davis authors hypothesize that plants being defended by man-made ...
    (rec.gardens.edible)
  • Re: answer to kenney former Re: Spirit Pond, Maine
    ... > As for my comments on Inger misunderstanding, ... > references, which are checkable from independent sources. ... >> constant stream of abuse at Inger, without going to all that trouble ... You resort to a lot of mindless demanding of references, ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: KRS lake
    ... the dating in the Kensington area was not ... This is, of course, the same excuse that Inger used about four ... "I gues you better learn a bit more about Geology. ... And no references that support her claims. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: any hydro peeps here?
    ... abstract articles of papers you can't get, Amazon book reviews of books you ... the hydroponics ... references to references that suggest it MAY BE true. ... "The Davis authors hypothesize that plants being defended by man-made ...
    (rec.gardens.edible)