Re: Were one to read Robert Best and Walter Reinhold..., our Flood is local with Noah an historical figure

On Jul 7, 2:38 pm, "Peter Alaca" <p.al...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Tom McDonald <kilt...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > wrote:





Tedd Jacobs wrote:
"Carl" wrote...
On Jul 6, 4:13 pm, "Tedd Jacobs" <tjac...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:
"Carl" wrote...

<snip>

[...]

Do we like the proposal that Noah was a king in Sumer around 2900
BC?
no. do you have a reference to support this assertion?

p.s. mark your snips.
Please pay attention to the 2 links on Best and Reinhold...
respectively I already
gave in our Thread here on sci.arch that I started.

If you click them, I believe you will agree that I indeed have "a
reference to support
this assertion".

no, i dont agree.

Carl is presently having the same frustrating experience in
talk.origins that he is having here. Apparently, two complete
Usenet newsgroups, both populated by some truly gifted people,
cannot seem to grasp Carl's gifts, nor appreciate that he offers
wonders beyond their ken. If they would only give themselves over
to his Socratic ministrations.

And in soc.history.ancient.
(Not sure about the truly gifted people though)



I wonder whether Marc Washington might be moved to converse with
Carl? They are both prophets without honor in their adopted
newsgroups.

--
p.a.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

On the contrary soc.history.ancient is a big success for me.
All my evidence was put into the links I gave. All done.
This means my priority was to get backup onto NG(s).
For conversation to follow is almost too much
for me to expect but I could be wrong.

I was polite but firm with people throughout.

If people don't want to click links or aren't interested,
so be it.

BTW, I told Matt Giwer that it would most probably take
3 solid hours of study for him to go thru the 4 links I gave
on calendar - OPENING WEDGE, not based on "ThieringCodes",
for the reader to get a handle on Thiering Methodology -
a VERY DIFFICULT SUBJECT!

Let's move on to archaeology, please.

.

Relevant Pages