Re: France's earliest winery found

On Jul 24, 11:26 am, "Uwe Müller" <uwemuel...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
"Jack Linthicum" <jacklinthi...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> schrieb im Newsbeitragnews:1184887668.181336.257630@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On Jul 19, 2:46 pm, "Uwe Müller" <uwemuel...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:> "Jack Linthicum" <jacklinthi...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> schrieb im

Newsbeitragnews:1184780992.366540.101030@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Jul 17, 9:22 am, "Uwe Müller" <uwemuel...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:> "Jack

Linthicum" <jacklinthi...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> schrieb im

Newsbeitragnews:1184496657.146706.21580@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> On

Jul 15, 3:26 am, "Uwe Müller" <uwemuel...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:>



"Hayabusa" <peregr...@xxxxxxxxxxx> schrieb im

Newsbeitragnews:uikf93h09spvj1pl16qoe5isc3k6p9gn4a@xxxxxxxxxx

On Fri, 13 Jul 2007 14:53:34 +0200, "Uwe Müller"
<uwemuel...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Sorry, must have missed your answer.

> snip >



Wouldn't be easier to just say "I don't agree with anything anyone
else writes on any subject" and leave it at that?

If you pretend, just for a minute, you had an open mind, and qould treat
your position as you treat some kooks here, you'd have to agree that there
is no nil zero hard evidence for wine being traded in the 5th-4th c. BC up
the Rhone.

Instead you rely on supposed authorities, who support the idea of a wine
trade, as the kooks do, without any evidence given and without any argument
why they believe that is true.

If you believe an unknown ship in an unknown location from an unknown time
is evidence for a two million gallons a year wine trade through Marseille
and a trade monopoly across the whole of France in the 4th-5th c. BC, I
would put you in the same category as Inger, Carl and Matt and refrain from
commenting your exquisite pearls of wisdom in the future.

hth

have fun

Uwe Mueller

I have sent an email to the author of the "2.2 million gallons" piece
I cited asking for his reference. I have sent for this via
Interlibrary.

2005. Dietler, Michael. Consumption and Colonial Encounters in the
Rhône
Basin of France: A Study of Early Iron Age Political Economy.
Monographies
d'Archéologie Meditérranéenne, 21. Lattes, France: CNRS.


I live in a small beach town off shore in Florida, the libraries are
only fair so I have to depend on what I have and what I can get from
the Internet.

I argue from facts.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Frances earliest winery found
    ... Instead you rely on supposed authorities, who support the idea of a wine ... trade, as the kooks do, without any evidence given and without any argument ... If you believe an unknown ship in an unknown location from an unknown time ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Ancient Use Of Rafts - Leslie Dewan and Dorothy Hosler of MIT
    ... Ancient Maritime Trade on Balsa Rafts: ... Strong evidence of Andean-Mexican seagoing trade as ... American, archeology at Harvard University. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: Frances earliest winery found
    ... 'trade' as the way they managed the exchange. ... So how would the evidence for a 'monopoly in the French wine trade ... ... societies of southern France in the seventh century B.C. significantly ... the importation of wine could initially ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: ANCIENT MARINERS: Andean-Mexican seagoing trade
    ... > researcher says she has strong evidence they did. ... > is seaborne trade. ... > Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, and Western Mexico. ... that these South American marine ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: ANCIENT MARINERS: Andean-Mexican seagoing trade
    ... > researcher says she has strong evidence they did. ... > is seaborne trade. ... > Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, and Western Mexico. ... that these South American marine ...
    (sci.anthropology)