Re: First time telescope buyer

From: Chuck (cscappaticci_at_adelphia.net)
Date: 10/17/04 

Date: Sun, 17 Oct 2004 15:39:52 -0600

Well I have a goto telescope, but I always align on the wrong two stars so I
don't cheat. 

-- 
Thanks,
     Chuck
"matt" <mariusrf@bellsouth.net> wrote in message
news:y1Bcd.14297$pi7.13773@bignews4.bellsouth.net...
> >SaberScorpX wrote:
> >>>Being able to demonstrate a knowledge of the sky to others gratifies
> >>>the performer's ego, but serves no other practical or public good.
> >>
> >>
> >> Another lazy GoTo-er's defense of their lack of starhopping skills.
> >> Do we learn to drive, rather than take a bus, simply to gratify our
egos?
> >> Demonstrating a knowledge of the sky sure comes in handy when you're
> hosting
> >> star parties.
> >> Anyone else remember when starhopping was a natural part of the
learning
> >> process?
>
> I'm always perplexed by the amount of antiGOTO present on SAA . Apparently
> lots of people who have never understood this technology are jumping to
> denigrate it.
> If one wants to learn the sky, starhopping and all that, the GOTO scope is
a
> better tool than a dob . Here's why:
>
> - to manually move the scope, as a dob would move, all one has to do is
push
> the arrow keys . There's no law that you MUST only use the GOTO mode. Slew
> manually to your heart's desire to anything you could find in the sky,
learn
> everything using star charts, books, star hopping . Use the fastest slew
to
> reach the general area, then switch to a x2 rate to find the object. Try
> slewing at x2 with a dob .
>     -in contrast , the problem with the dob is that bearing surfaces need
to
> be good,  scope needs to be well balanced , or else it won't go or it
won't
> stay where you wanted it . Much harder to find a target .
>
>     -after finding the target, the lousy GOTO scope tracks it . Darn . No
> need to worry about going away to look for another eyepiece, or let
someone
> else take a peek who's not an expert nudger. Come back  a half hour later,
> the target is still in the eyepiece FOV, but just leave that dob for one
> minute and you'd have to find your target again . You'd need to spend more
> money with the dob to buy a tracking platform, add 50 lbs weight of said
> platform, and add another step to your ladder due to the extra 6 inches
the
> platform adds to the eyepiece height .
>
>     -If you're learning the sky, using manual slews with no GOTO, just
slew
> the scope wherever you wanted , and then key in the "Identify" command
> Autostar has . It will instantly display the name of whatever you see in
the
> eyepiece .
> Yes, then you can confirm it with star charts, computer programs etc, and
> return to your target 10 minutes later , because it's still there.
>
>     Bottom line,  a GOTO scope can do what a dob does and more. The dob
> can't do what a GOTO scope does .
> The most glaring ommission from all GOTO critics is the manual slew,
> tracking and identify functions of a GOTO scope that could be easily and
> efficiently used to learn starhopping. As a matter of fact, they're far
> better tools for starhopping than what a dob mount could offer .
>     GOTO doesn't even cost that much more at least here in the USA . A new
> Meade lxd75 6" Newtonian sells for $460 or so, just $200 over the price of
> the same size dob , but you get the GOTO equatorial mount with it .
>
> If you're handy, you can motorize any dob for less than DSC's cost . Buy a
> set of Meade DS motors and Autostar , assuming you're a beginner with some
> technical expertise , but that's another thread ;-)
>
> best regards,
> Matt Tudor
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>

Relevant Pages

  • Re: First time telescope buyer
    ... I can move my Babylon 8 Dob from one part of the sky to another in seconds ... person wants goto, that's fine with me, but do NOT go and shoot down star ... > If one wants to learn the sky, starhopping and all that, the GOTO scope is a> better tool than a dob. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Does the ETX 70 AT share the same mount as the ETX 90?
    ... >I eventually plan to get an inexpensive DOB... ... The fork is make of tiny plastic parts held together by small self tapping ... tiny dots or maybe tiny disks, just a tad larger than the distorted stars. ... I was never able to enjoy its goto capabilities, ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Observing Projects
    ... Some were found with GoTo, others with DSCs, and many with a Dob, a Telrad ... and the other two scopes were a 10" and 12.5" Dobs. ... my project is to become more proficient at imaging. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: SCTs are dying ...
    ... GoTo altazimuth FM SCT's provide no benefit over a GoTo ... >> Track Dob of equal aperture. ... > SCT transport by auto over Dob, unless the Dob has a wide field focal ... I don't understand the part about not fitting a scope on a hand truck ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: 8" Newtonian choice
    ... leg tripod and the GoTo system to the GP head. ... Celestron 8" F5 on the Advanced Series mount is stable enough, ... choice between my 10 inch DOB and the EQ mounted Konus, ... really need "rotating rings." ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)