Re: Another DOB question...

From: Jon Isaacs (jonisaacs_at_aol.com)
Date: 10/31/04


Date: 31 Oct 2004 04:13:31 GMT


>Greetings...
>
>Well, I'm struggling through the vast mine fields of Dob purchasing...I'm
>starting to think it's not worth it...The big Dobs are very, very cumbersome
>and quality is very, very expensive...

If I remember correctly, the last scope you were looking at was an 16 inch F5.8
DOB. At first that seemed ideal but now it appears you have come to realize
that a scope that is 8 feet long has some disadvantages.

This does not mean that all scopes larger than 8inches are so cumbersome as to
be unuseable, it just means you need to be careful in choosing.

Putting a nice mirror in that Orion scope is not going buy you the advantages
of 4 inches of added aperture. That factor of 2.25 in light gathering is way
too big to overcome.

My suggestion is to take it easy and check out some different scopes in person
and see what you think. A fast 12.5 inch scope can be quite portable, mine
fits in my '92 Escort and I can say that it out performs my XT-8 in just about
every way imagineable.

jon



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Celestron NexStar 80 vs Firstscope 76
    ... >I never said to beat DOB on planets, ... is qualitatively, not quantatively, and it is at a much higher cost per inch ... performer than the 6" OA, which is in turn a better performer than the 8" F6 ... Anyone who has used the three scopes I just listed, ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Recommend a telescope (im so confused!)
    ... Astrophotography and "Dob" don't mix. ... >the scope which could make finding DSO a real burden. ... the cheap price is the idea. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Top 6 reasons to own a 12.5 inch or larger dobsonian telescope
    ... >> Obsession 25, SBIG CCD, and Optec field de-rotator. ... > images of; open and globulars clusters (and I'm not talking about the ... don't need a driving mount to do CCD with any size scope. ... Dob goes a long way toward helping with this problem and that's one of the ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Top 6 reasons to own a 12.5 inch or larger dobsonian telescope
    ... >>> becomes common in 5 years or less. ... For that matter with drift-scan imaging you ... > don't need a driving mount to do CCD with any size scope. ... > near future they will be able to get a 14 to 18 inch Dob that will be easier ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: SCTs are dying ...
    ... GoTo altazimuth FM SCT's provide no benefit over a GoTo ... >> Track Dob of equal aperture. ... > SCT transport by auto over Dob, unless the Dob has a wide field focal ... I don't understand the part about not fitting a scope on a hand truck ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)