Re: contamination of other worlds/ moons?

From: Davoud (star_at_sky.net)
Date: 01/23/05


Date: Sun, 23 Jan 2005 10:23:50 -0500

John Lingenfelter:
> With out [sic] landing of probes on Mars, Venus and now Titan, I can't help but
> wonder if we're also contaminating those worlds? I doubt if anything would
> survive externally on the probes after going through space, but what about
> tools, cutters, etc that come from inside?

The answer is "It is entirely possible that we have contaminated Mars,
Venus, our own Moon, and Titan with microörganisms, but there is a good
chance that we will never know if this is true." The likelihood that
humans will ever explore Venus or Titan is vanishingly remote, and Mars
also seems to be a improbable target, in spite of grandiose talk here
and there. As for going back to the Moon, for what purpose?

Consider this: suppose life on Earth sprang from microörganisms that
were brought here -- intentionally or not -- by a visiting space probe
from a (then) nearby star very early in Earth's history. I can imagine
the radioed report: "Landed on a sea shore. Gullies seen were probably
created by liquid water... No life detected..."

Davoud

-- 
usenet *at* davidillig dawt com


Relevant Pages

  • Re: Life on Venus is absolute hell, but doable
    ... The problem is: what's life. ... You are talking about possibility to survive of Earth forms on Venus. ... Main probe has several probes to jump on Fobos. ... > capable of surviving Venus, at least at full capacity while operating ...
    (sci.space.history)
  • Re: Lamarcks Tree
    ... > common ancestral form and even drew up a 'tree of life'. ... First let me address the issue of spontaneous generation. ... Mars probes) are designed to look for, and how, and why. ... any yet found on Earth. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Fermi paradox, your own belief?
    ... >> even conservative estimates suggest that adanced life in the galaxy is ... against any of the probes being close enough to detect/respond to us. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: We are, a mass extinction event.
    ... Well what if along with these probes, they sent out a bit of DNA. ... life, all over the universe because we might see that as maybe making ... It seems odd to me, that life began on earth, shortly after the earth ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: More Methane on Mars
    ... >> contaminating any life that might be there. ... > I agree that robot missions should come first, ... Me thinks "contaminating" that planet with life could be the best ...
    (sci.geo.geology)