Re: TV85 vs. Orion 80ED
From: David Nakamoto (res07oeg_at_verizon.net)
Date: 01/30/05
- Next message: Bill Becker: "Re: Problems with posts appearing"
- Previous message: Ioannis: "Re: Sam Wormley is Wrong (was: WHAT'S NEW...)"
- In reply to: Ed T: "Re: TV85 vs. Orion 80ED"
- Next in thread: Szaki: "Re: TV85 vs. Orion 80ED"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Date: Sun, 30 Jan 2005 20:15:15 GMT
"Ed T" <reply@thegroup.thx> wrote in message
news:Rf4Ld.1820$cl1.263@newsread3.news.pas.earthlink.net...
>
> <clydec@nyc.rr.com> wrote in message
>>
>> I have never seen anyone say that the Orion out-performs the TV85
>> except you. For those interested, you might read Tom Trusock's very in
>> depth review on CloudyNights.
>>
>> Clyde
>>
>
> The problem with the TV85, as I see it, is excessive owner satisfaction. The
> only way to meet this head on is to replace them all with Orion EDs. Once the
> edification inherent in this self denial has been fully realized, one can move
> on to more advanced ascetism.
The "excessive" owner satisfaction is due in this case to quality in the optics
and the overall construction. I don't own one myself, and I can't see myself
doing so simply because I'm not the type that goes for the expensive things, but
I've seen through a couple, and even did a side-by-side-by-side comparison of
images between, if memory serves, the Telvue 102(?), a 125mm f/5 Syntha
refractor, and a Celestron 150mm refractor (I don't remember the focal ratio).
Comparing apples to oranges to orangutans (^_^), but what the heck, and it was
the guy with the 150mm who wanted to compare. We picked a large crater with
smaller ones inside it, and went from scope to scope to see how many we could
see. Wish I could remember the crater.
Anyway, the score was pretty consistently - Telvue 4 craters, Syntha 2,
Celestron 1. This was only one example of each telescope of course, and mileage
is going to vary widely for the inexpensive refractors (the Syntha and the
Celestron), but from viewing through other examples I believe the quality of the
Telvues is pretty much guaranteed with a few exceptions. Not so with the
others, at least not to the quality standards Telvue sets for themselves.
So whenever someone, anyone, says something that goes against the consensus,
they're the exception that makes the rule, or simple a troll spouting off, and
in considering what to do with such positions, keep in mind that a wise man once
said that the race does not always go to the swiftest or the strongest, but
that's the way to bet.
--
Sincerely,
--- Dave
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It don't mean a thing
unless it has that certain "je ne sais quoi"
Duke Ellington
----------------------------------------------------------------------
- Next message: Bill Becker: "Re: Problems with posts appearing"
- Previous message: Ioannis: "Re: Sam Wormley is Wrong (was: WHAT'S NEW...)"
- In reply to: Ed T: "Re: TV85 vs. Orion 80ED"
- Next in thread: Szaki: "Re: TV85 vs. Orion 80ED"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Relevant Pages
|
|
