Re: logarithmic image???



Ike wrote:

What is a logaritmic image? Are they lowballing us by saying that the camera isn't actually working properly?

http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/deepimpact/multimedia/di-impactor-1-070305.html

Not at all. They are presenting it as a logarithmic image because it allows the full dynamic range of their camera to be shown on the early release images. Seems like by far the best option to me given the inherent uncertainty in how bright the hot spot would be.


I would much rather see the full dynamic range image in logarithmic mode than a simple minded linear transformed version where either all shadow detail is lost or all highlights are burnt out.

Almost every image that you see has been subject to some form of non-linear transformation of the luminosity. The original raw data will be used for the quantitative science, but very high dynamic range data does not look good either on print media or on consumer video monitors. They have to do something like this to render the data accessible to the public.

Regards,
Martin Brown
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Lets make it useful.. Re: Quick question ???
    ... Get a CHDK capable camera and use "Zebra Mode": ... EV to ensure that no part of your changing scene is lost, ... All digital cameras have more dynamic range ... Sometimes you can improve a photo by clipping highlights and shadows. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: Which camera has the best dynamic range?
    ... F100fd or the Nikon CoolPix 610. ... Possibly the camera you already own. ... back the missing white highlights, although it may require more than ... attention was paid to improving dynamic range in the F100fd's ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: dynamic range
    ... white so a high DR camera is actually going to be a bit less contrasty. ... conversions to recover blown highlights. ... You can initially clip the dynamic range and then later expand it. ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)
  • Re: Lets make it useful.. Re: Quick question ???
    ... camera with higher DR, ie a DSLR.) ... for reasons Vern chooses to ignore. ... P&S smaller sensor cameras can and do have wider dynamic range than larger ... You reveal your total lack of talent as a photographer. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: To RAW or not to RAW?
    ... >>>Digital Camera Raw versus Jpeg Conversion Losses ... >> So much for the supposed dynamic range of a JPEG format. ... >>>in electrons) and indeed some sensors ... Read noise, which is not included in the data, is exactly ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)