Re: Which galaxy looks like a galaxy in a 8" Dob?



CNP wrote:

> Is there any galaxy that will really look like a galaxy (distinct elliptical
> or spiral shape) in a 8" Dob?
>
> We live in a city in North America and our northern and eastern skies have
> heavy light pollution.

To summarize and agree with what everyone else has been saying:

An 8-inch scope can show a fair amount of structural detail in a large
number of galaxies. However, even moderate levels of light pollution --
let alone the levels found in any major city -- are lethal to galaxy
views.

If you really want to view galaxies, it is *essential* to take your
scope
and travel to a reasonably dark site. Dark skies are *much* more
important than aperture for viewing galaxies. Which isn't to say that
aperture isn't important, mind you -- it is, very much so.

In my opinion, the *only* galaxy visible from the Northern Hemisphere
that shows really interesting detail in an 8-inch scope under heavy
light
pollution is M82.

My number-two choice might come as a surprise to many people:
it's M33. What's surprising is that most beginners can't even detect
this galaxy under typical suburban light pollution, let alone see
detail in it. But if you can see it at all, you have some chance of
detecting the beginning of spiral structure. And the emission area
NGC 604 is visible in an 8-inch scope even under very poor skies.

- Tony Flanders

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Which galaxy looks like a galaxy in a 8" Dob?
    ... >Is there any galaxy that will really look like a galaxy (distinct elliptical ... >or spiral shape) in a 8" Dob? ... If your light pollution is bad, you will probably have difficulty seeing ... galaxies as anything other than faint blobs. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: what galaxy
    ... People have referred me to the Andromeda galaxy but I'll be ... In my opinion you should start out by locating the brighter galaxies mentioned here, not for detail, but simply to become familiar with where they are. ... Years later they are now super easy to see, and detail is not out of the question for M82 even in a small scope. ... M51 is my favorite galaxy to observe in any scope, as it is likely to reveal its spiral arms with relative ease, given darkness, experience, and 6" or so of aperture. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Worst winter skies for years
    ... ten nights that were clear and moonless (what I need to pursue galaxy ... viewing). ... scope was out perhaps two times for the whole season. ... (aligning new finder, collimating SCT, etc.). ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Worst winter skies for years
    ... ten nights that were clear and moonless (what I need to pursue galaxy ... viewing). ... scope was out perhaps two times for the whole season. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Best way to remove annoying galaxy?
    ... > There appears to be a large galaxy that is obstructing my view of ... mirrors and use them to guide light from behind the galaxy ... Shortly after that everything will be redshifted into oblivion, ... won't even be able to see as far as your scope in the yard anymore! ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)

Quantcast