Re: Grinding a mirror vs buying complete



Dan wrote:
I am beginning to think about building my own Newtonian. Is there a fairly
major saving in grinding one's own mirror vs purchasing a completed mirror
from one of the top makers?

No. And if it is your first effort it is unlikely to be a very good
mirror unless you get experienced help. On the other hand, if your
first mirror reflects a photon in any direction you'll be justifiably
proud of it and you may be hooked and on your way to that perfect
10-incher -- or larger.

I know a few amateur telescope makers, and it seems to me that ATM is
almost a separate hobby to amateur astronomy -- the two endeavours are
not always closely linked. That's /not/ to say that ATM is not a valid,
worthy, and rewarding hobby.

Also, can anyone recommend a good book on making a Newtonian?

Not I, but there are tons of books on the subject. Willman-Bell
<http://willbell.com/> and Sky & Telescope <http://tinyurl.com/a5hnx>
might be good starting points.

Davoud

"Forgive me for being so dense. Please explain once more how shining
spotlights on /my/ house improves security at /your/ house."

--
usenet *at* davidillig dawt com
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Grinding a mirror vs buying complete
    ... major saving in grinding one's own mirror vs purchasing a completed ... from one of the top makers? ... If you price the time, and buy everything at full price, savings (relative ... More recently, looking at the prices ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Grinding a mirror vs buying complete
    ... major saving in grinding one's own mirror vs purchasing a completed mirror ... will be much better than the worst mirror that the "top makers" produce, ... their mirrors are of uniform high quality. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Grinding a mirror vs buying complete
    ... major saving in grinding one's own mirror vs purchasing a completed mirror ... Don't do it to save money, do it because you can produce a mirror that will be much better than the worst mirror that the "top makers" produce, and with some time, can rival or exceed their best. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Grinding a mirror vs buying complete
    ... major saving in grinding one's own mirror vs purchasing a completed mirror ... from one of the top makers? ... IMO grinding your own mirror is not something you should do if your main ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: What have we learned from Hubble about building telescopes?
    ... An independent lab should test the mirror. ... Or barring that, let an ATM have a crack at it with a homemade, $10 ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)

Quantcast