Help on filter factors and Wratten filters transmission percent



I am developing a table of transmission and filter factors for use in
astrophotography.
http://members.csolutions.net/fisherka/astronote/astrophoto/FilterTableWratten.html

I am not sure if I am doing this properly. I got stuck on the fact that
the tranmission percentages reported for Wratten filters in
manufacturer inserts do not match the transmission factors in Kodak.
_____. Kodak Photographic Filters Handbook. Kodak Publication B-3.

For example, the product insert for a Meade #12 Yellow filter is 74%.
But in looking at the spec in Kodak Publication B3, the #12 yellow
filter is a cut-off filter that, beginning at 580nm has 90%
transmission. Similarly, the #25 Orion Red filter product insert lists
a transmission factor of 14%. The Kodak spec publication states at
680nm, the filter has a 90% transmission.

I resolved this by deciding that for photograph purposes, the "correct"
transmission percent of the filter should be judged by its percent of
transmission at the peak bandpass of interest. For cut-off filters, it
is the wavelength at which 90% transmission occurs.

I would appreciate some feedback on whether this process is correct.

A narrative of how I developed the table is attached.

Thanks, Canopus56

P.S. - Table development

A copy of figures and tables from Kodak Pub. No. 3 were located on the
internet.
Bell, Thomas. 2005. Kodak Wratten Gelatin Filter Transmission Curves.
(Webpage) (Reproductions from Kodak Publication B-3.
http://www.geocities.com/thombell/curves.html

An old post in this newsgroup published wavelength/transmission tables.

Repacholi, Paul. Oct. 27, 1992. Re: Wratten filter data. Usenet Post
to group rec.photo. (Table of Wratten filter passbands and %
transmission) Usenet Message-ID: <1992Oct27.183652.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
(Corresponds to Kodak B-3 charts and tables)

The Repacholi post and Kodak Pub. No. 3 were consistent.

I then collected product inserts from my own gear and from the web.
The following website is illustrative.
http://www.analyticalsci.com/Astronomy/Filters/Filters_Described_Meade.htm

Then the product inserts were reviewed and a list of filters and
transmission factors were built. In a couple of instances, the
manufacturer's transmission factor at peak wavelength had to be
estimated from a chart in the insert.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Filters - Quality
    ... transmission line environment, so this is ... every filter introduces its own impedance (a complex ... We also try to ensure the ADSL ... Simple designs are poorest at this blocking ...
    (uk.telecom.broadband)
  • Re: "Transmission Flush": Needed ?
    ... important because good shifting depends on good flow through the filter ... opportunity to wipe the layer of pond scum from the bottom of the pan. ... I personally prefer to drop the transmission pan every few years, ... transmissions as requiring no maintenance under "normal" conditions: ...
    (rec.autos.tech)
  • Re: Filtermag work well with a 4 runner ?
    ... There is a magnet for the transmission and another for the ... The transmission already has a magnet, and I think the diff does too. ... state that the oil filter mag will help prevent a catastrophic engine ... but what is your pick for best and second best air filter for (for ...
    (alt.autos.toyota)
  • Re: Filtermag work well with a 4 runner ?
    ... There is a magnet for the transmission and another for the ... The transmission already has a magnet, and I think the diff does too. ... state that the oil filter mag will help prevent a catastrophic engine ... but what is your pick for best and second best air filter for (for ...
    (alt.autos.toyota)
  • Re: Moon Hoax people
    ... actually getting anything safely deployed upon the moon. ... said about those Kodak moments, that which simply can't be if having ... terrestrial via xenon lamp illumination exposure had to offer. ... filter which should have terminated nearly everything below 500 nm, ...
    (sci.space.history)