Re: I'm SICK of the theory of "panspermia"



except to point out that the very atoms which make up Earth, the
Sun, and the solar system, et cetera were seeded -



Rich wrote:

Why would they think Earth was "seeded" with life? Why not start with
and prove or disprove life originated here? What is the attraction for
scientists of this theory?

Hollow spheres found in a primordial meteorite could yield clues to the
origin of life on Earth.

Scientists say that "bubbles" like those in the Tagish Lake meteorite
may have helped along chemical processes important for the emergence of
life.

The globules could also be older than our Solar System - their
chemistry suggests they formed at about -260C, near "absolute zero".

Details of the work by Nasa scientists are published in the journal
Science.

Analysis of the bubbles shows they arrived on Earth in the meteorite
and are not terrestrial contaminants.

These hollow spheres could have provided a protective envelope for the
raw organic molecules needed for life.

Dr Lindsay Keller of Nasa's Johnson Space Center (JSC) in Houston,
Texas, told BBC News that some scientists believed such structures were
"a step in the right direction" to making a cell wall.

But he emphasised that the globules in Tagish Lake were in no way
equivalent to a cell. The hollow spheres seem to be empty, but they do
have organic molecules on their surfaces.

Mike Zolensky, a Nasa mineralogist, commented: "If, as we suspect, this
type of meteorite has been falling on to Earth throughout its entire
history, then the Earth was seeded with these organic globules at the
same time life was first forming here."

Co-author Keiko Nakamura-Messenger of JSC told BBC News: "We reported
only 26 globules in this paper, because they are small and hard to
analyse. But we have seen hundreds in a small area. We can estimate
that there are billions of them in this meteorite."

The ratios of different forms, or isotopes, of the elements hydrogen
and nitrogen in the meteorite are very unusual, which suggests the
structures did not come from Earth, say the scientists.

"The isotopic ratios in these globules show that they formed at
temperatures of about -260C, near absolute zero," said co-author Scott
Messenger, also from Johnson Space Center.

"The organic molecules most likely originated in the cold molecular
cloud that gave birth to our Solar System, or at the outermost reaches
of the early Solar System."

The Tagish Lake meteorite was collected immediately after its fall over
Canada in 2000. It has been maintained in a frozen state, minimising
the potential for terrestrial contamination.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Im SICK of the theory of "panspermia"
    ... TROLLspermia is the theory that the the seeds of TROLLS are ubiquitous ... Hollow spheres found in a primordial meteorite could yield clues to the ... Analysis of the bubbles shows they arrived on Earth in the meteorite ... But he emphasised that the globules in Tagish Lake were in no way ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Solar System Slightly Older Than Previously Thought
    ... Ancient Solar System research published in Nature ... Dr Joel Baker, Senior Lecturer in the School of Earth Sciences, is the ... from a meteorite found in the Sahara Desert ...
    (sci.space.news)
  • Murchison Meteorite Contains Complex Organic Molecules
    ... Previously unknown organic molecules have been discovered ... in a 100 kg meteorite that hit Australia in 1969, ... suggesting that our early Solar System contained a soup of ... "soup" that led to the development of life on Earth. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: g@riskys perversity is a consequence of his perverse straw man
    ... the inspired Word of God. ... dependent on far more than the local forces in our tiny solar system. ... masses can make the Sun form a tight orbit around what is effectively ... Unfortunately no one has provided conclusive proof that the earth is ...
    (talk.origins)
  • g@riskys perversity is a consequence of his perverse straw man
    ... the inspired Word of God. ... dependent on far more than the local forces in our tiny solar system. ... incredibly complex motions of distant galaxies. ... Unfortunately no one has provided conclusive proof that the earth is ...
    (talk.origins)