Re: Palmer Conjecture

In message <1137342062.713098.196770@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Bruce <Bruce.Palmer@xxxxxx> writes 
Seeing a picture of an Einstein Ring got me wondering. Do you suppose
that a light beam that departs something going one direction would
eventually pass a light beam that departs the same source in very
different direction?



So I'm a little perplexed with the question of how we might know that
this is what we're seeing, if it is.  It would be a real shame if we
could theoretically see the same object many times but that the amount
of dark matter is so great that no light beam can actually make a round
trip.


You might look up the idea that the universe is a dodecahedron, which will apparently have an effect on the spectrum of the CMB. Look at <http://physicsweb.org/article/news/7/10/5> for instance.
Another way this is being examined is to see if there are actual repeating patterns in the background. Here's an example <http://www.etsu.edu/math/gardner/aas/empir.htm>
I don't know if anyone's looked for repeating patterns in the 3D structure of the universe. I'd think it would be impossible to tell, given the billions of years that have passed since the light set out.
There are lots of other possibilities if the universe isn't a simple "flat" structure. Try "horn universe", for instance <http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn4879>
Of course, going even further out there's the idea that the CMB might have an artificial pattern, in which case there's possibly no way to tell the real shape :-)
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Palmer Conjecture
    ... > that a light beam that departs something going one direction would ... > circle by the mass of the entire universe. ... If space is infinite, and matter ...
    (sci.astro)
  • Palmer Conjecture
    ... that a light beam that departs something going one direction would ... circle by the mass of the entire universe. ... is true, and there was no dark matter in space, then the sky would have ...
    (sci.astro)
  • Re: Riding on a photo
    ... > if he was riding on a light beam. ... > what the universe would look like from the point of view of a photon. ... Einstein trying to imagine what the universe would look like if he was ...
    (sci.physics.research)