Re: Solar absorption lines



George Dishman wrote:
"Scott" <ss@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:44b10377$0$22123$afc38c87@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Hi George,

Thanks for joining in this discussion.

Atoms in the chromosphere can scatter in all
directions but they are only illuminated from
one side, that facing the Sun.

Yes. But I don't see how that can create absorption lines.

If a patch of gas is illuminated by a source at
some brightness covering 2 pi steradians and then
emits the same energy into 4 pi sterardians it
must appear less bright.

The geometrical effect does thus reduce here the absorption lines only
to half the intensity of the continuum (as for subsequent scattering
events the radiation field is practically isotropic).

The explanation for the Fraunhofer lines must thus lie elsewhere. The
primary mechanism should be:

1) In the course of the scatterings, photons are shifted from the line
center into the line wings due to the Doppler effect.

2) Due to multiple scattering, photons within the line stay for such a
long time in the solar atmosphere that they have a high probability of
ionizing excited states of hydrogen (the density of the latter is too
small to affect any radiation that is going straight through (i.e. the
continuum), but for photons within the line the effective pathlength is
several orders of magnitude larger and photoionization of excited
states will be important). The photoionization process leads then
subsequently again to a photon on recombination of the photoelectron,
but this will have a completely different wavelength, i.e. like for
mechanism (1) photons will be lost from the line.

Thomas

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: |GG| Re: The Joy of Pixel Density
    ... There is not much variation in the total number of photons capturable per unit of area; most of the variation is in the rate they are caught. ... These include the absorption length in silicon, ... limiting the maximum number electrons captured in a semiconductor ... So an I understand from that, small pixels get muddled data from deeper penetrating photons as they cross under to adjacent pixels. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: Fluorescent Spectrum - Spikes vs Broad Slopes
    ... atoms in a high pressure mercury lamp is determined mostly ... Therefore absorption of 254 nm ... photons can increase the density of the state. ... "Self-absorption usually happens with resonance lines, ...
    (sci.engr.lighting)
  • Re: Any excimer knowledgeable people here?
    ... > I've been trying to find absorption spectra of xenon dimers on the ... OK -- the energy is still in the atoms, ... upper energy levels, and still has a chance to get out by emitting ... photons, either on E4->E3 (which puts it back into E3, ready to try ...
    (sci.optics)
  • Re: Fluorescent Spectrum - Spikes vs Broad Slopes
    ... atoms in a high pressure mercury lamp is determined mostly ... Therefore absorption of 254 nm ... a low pressure mercury discharge, ... is controlled solely by absorption of 254nm photons, ...
    (sci.engr.lighting)
  • Re: Evidence against emission theories
    ... "The connection between Rayleigh scattering and refraction is very ... The waves are re-radiated by the DIPOLES ... induced in the scatterers by the incident field are incoherent, ... photons will pass preceeding groups of slow photons and produce multiple ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)