Re: What time of the year is the moon closest to the Earth??



Dear dlham:

dlham@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
....
Thanks Dave

You are welcome. I was surprised I could find the answer that easily.

http://www.fourmilab.ch/images/peri_apo/

This article states that "the moon is at perigee relative
to the earth when earth is at apogee relative to the sun
and the moon is at apogee relative to the earth when
the earth is at perigee relative to the sun."

Can anyone tell me if there is a logical explanation
why this "coincidence" occurs?? Why the moon is
closest to the earth when the earth is farthest from the
sun and visa versa??

Conservation of angular momentum. The *system* of Earth (E) and the
Moon (M) is not isolated from the Sun (S). The SEM system angular
momentum is constant (ignoring all the other bodies in the solar
system). So you can think of M picking up (or holding) some momentum
(however briefly) from the SE system.

Three-body problems are always thorny. Hopefully you will get a better
/ clearer answer from others here.

David A. Smith

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why do the Sun, and Moon, appear to be the same size from earth?
    ... The distance from the Earth to the Moon is 108 times the diameter of ... you can fit 108 moons between the Earth and the Moon – ... and the Sun. ... the distance from the Earth to the Sun is ~107.4697 diameters of the ...
    (rec.music.classical.guitar)
  • Re: QuestionEvolution.com News
    ... Here's the Solar System page from the site, ... After several thousand eccentric orbits around the sun, ... gets captured by Saturn, and there's another moon. ... I suspect the Earth and the Sun started of pretty much the same, ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: need arbitration about a physics problem
    ... | The author claimed that you when stand on Jupiter's moon Io, ... | gravitational field due to Jupiter alone: ... significantly farther from the Sun than Earth is, ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: The Heavenly Match: A Cosmic Oddity
    ... occurrence on earth - at least once a year somewhere on the globe. ... Where the ratio of the sun to moon size is ... It's just a coincidence. ... each with a random number of moons and moon sizes. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Some Pathetic Apologetic Arguments
    ... leaves naught, it spares naught. ... to the distinction between heaven and earth, ... In general the sun provides the energy and the moon ...
    (soc.religion.islam)