Labels and Obfuscations
From: Gil Lawton (gillawton_at_earthlink.net)
Date: 02/19/05
- Next message: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Haldane's Dilemma"
- Previous message: Birdbrain13: "Re: Human genetic diversity in Africa"
- Next in thread: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Maybe reply: John Edser: "RE: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Maybe reply: John Edser: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Date: Sat, 19 Feb 2005 18:40:33 -0500 (EST)
Labels can be wonderful tools for
compressing voluminous, complex
parameters into a single whole --
even a whole that may be greater
than the sum of its parts. A
label such as "natural selection"
or "existentialism" or "freedom"
can speed the surfing intellect
on a valid and beneficial course,
by avoiding the necessity for
voluminous redundant
explanations, and frequent
disclaimers.
In their beginnings, labels can
be the most obsequious of good
servants -- honest, dependable,,
accurate, efficient, undemanding,
unintimidating, benign...
But, alas, unless great care is
taken by the originators of great
ideas, and also by those who come
along after them, and utilize
their legacies, these formerly good
servants can, and almost always
do, transmography into sinister
enemies of their master, eclipsing
his fame, twisting his words,
obscuring his intents, resisting
against the furtherance of his
legacies.
Do we not do greater honor to the
intellectual giants onto whose
shoulders we would climb if we
take great care to explain ourselves
clearly as we drop the labels that
were their names and the names
given to their contributions. And
do we not show proper respect for
them only by making certain we
misrepresent them accurately, and
make clear where our own ideas
depart from theirs, and serve
our own agendas.
- Next message: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Haldane's Dilemma"
- Previous message: Birdbrain13: "Re: Human genetic diversity in Africa"
- Next in thread: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Perplexed in Peoria: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Maybe reply: John Edser: "RE: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Maybe reply: John Edser: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Reply: Jim McGinn: "Re: Labels and Obfuscations"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Relevant Pages
|