Re: Question: Philosophy of Science - is it Relevant?



> my friend, a Philosopher of Science, thinks that
> Philosophy of Science has an impact on scientific thinking

First there's the thing, then there's the philosophy about the thing.
It's a one-way process. The philosopher presumes too much when
he thinks his efforts in philosophizing about something are anything
like doing the thing itself.

As to the claim of having an impact, that should be illustrated
with examples, if it's true. I don't think that because of Kuhn,
new paradigms find easier acceptance. I don't think I define
things better than others do because I learned about the
definiens and the definiendum etc.

Philosophy is fun. We do it for its own sake. It can give us
perspective, which ennobles and calms our thinking.

Insofar as philosophy affects science, it *is* science.

Cliff


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Spanning Two Eras of Relativity
    ... "First Principles of a NEW System of Philosophy"? ... the Holy Ghost beareth record of this Scripture received by the ... Nobel Prize for Economic Science. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Spanning Two Eras of Relativity
    ... "First Principles of a NEW System of Philosophy"? ... the Holy Ghost beareth record of this Scripture received by the ... Nobel Prize for Economic Science. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Spanning Two Eras of Relativity
    ... "First Principles of a NEW System of Philosophy"? ... the Holy Ghost beareth record of this Scripture received by the ... Nobel Prize for Economic Science. ...
    (talk.atheism)
  • Spanning Two Eras of Relativity
    ... "First Principles of a NEW System of Philosophy"? ... the Holy Ghost beareth record of this Scripture received by the ... Nobel Prize for Economic Science. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Proposal - a new strategy to counter anti-evolutionists
    ... >>>agree and then press for adding a philosophy of science course to the ... a philosophy of science course of this sort will be ... >>>taught by both a proponent of ID and of evolution. ... proposing originally. ...
    (talk.origins)