Re: Hamilton's rule




Tim Tyler wrote:

> > There is more than one way to define "gene". A definition
> > as one base pair can be a useful definition. One book I read
> > defined gene something like this: part of a genome.
> > Thus by that definition, a gene could be a collection of
> > bits of DNA (even on different chromosomes, I think)
> > that coded for a set of proteins that worked together
> > to produce some particular trait or behaviour. [...]
>
> It appears that you found an unorthodox definition of the term
> "gene", that contradicts much established usage in biology.

You're a deceptive fool. First tell us the, supposedly, orthodox
definition. You can't because no such definition exists.

>
> Maybe McGinn has that book as well. Care to name and shame?

You first. Put up or shut up.

Jim


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... Tim Tyler tim@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:- ... >> defined gene something like this: ... The only "shame" here was Tim's futile attempt to misuse an argument from ... authority in order to protect a concept that many others prefer, ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... > pair on a gene's function, and defining a single base pair as a gene. ... I don't agree about what might be a useful definition. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Underestimating r
    ... Tim Tyler tim@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:- ... Because the empirical fitness of one body is ... never just the simple sum of the fitness of each gene within that body, ... > sons should be chopped up and fed to his daughters. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... Tim Tyler writes: ... > I don't think there's any terribly good reason why he should have ... > discussed the gene size issue - since any old gene size will do - ... Prev by Date: ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... DNA is supposedly your magic "gene" and let us test HR. ... > you want a term to refer to a single base or base pair, ... >> Your definition of a gene is some vague notion that you don't even ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)

Quantcast