Re: Hamilton's rule




Someone in some post in the last couple of weeks said that
genes for altruism towards distant relatives don't tend to
propagate. I disagree with this.

Suppose the following scenario: a species is organized
into large groups such that each group almost always breeds within
itself, not interbreeding much with other groups. Suppose
the groups are distinguished by visible phenological differences
but are not restricted to geographical areas. Suppose some
groups have genes that promote altruism towards individuals
within their group. If the benefit exceeds the cost, then
the genes will promote prosperity of the group, which will
tend to take up a larger geographical space. At the same
time, altruism genes within the group will tend to diminish
in frequency; the rates of these two opposing processes
depend on the ratio of cost to benefit. If the benefit is
large enough, the process of altruistic groups growing and
splitting into smaller groups and taking over territory or
habitat from non-altruistic groups will support the altruism
genes faster than those genes diminish in frequency within
each group.



.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... > world -- e.g. altruism. ... > is what Hamilton was, and I am, interested in -- we might as well count ... > proportion of identical genes are besides the point. ... it is not biology at all. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... >> proportion of identical genes are besides the point. ... because it is the relatedness at the altruism ... it is not biology at all. ... > which have a small epistatic effect on altruism or on wine preference. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... >> identical genes. ... The sequence similarity / proportion of identical genes ... world -- e.g. altruism. ... Say we have a three allele model, ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... > genes for altruism towards distant relatives don't tend to ... > groups have genes that promote altruism towards individuals ... If the benefit exceeds the cost, ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Kin Selection contradiction?
    ... > allele within those few generations is also small. ... never addresses the issue of genetic control over altruism. ... a fraction r containing genes IBD to genes in the actor; ... Calculate the total and per capita costs of altruism. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)

Loading