Challenge - can anyone start life without an energy source?

Challenge,
Does anyone know of an origin scenario where life starts
without an energy source? Can life begin independently from
all energy sources? Can anyone suggest an origin scenario
where life was NOT forced into being by an outside energy source?

If not,
then can we agree that life is a chemical reaction to an energy source
outside of it?

And because liquid water is needed, can we add that life is a chemical
reaction to an energy source outside of it within a specific temperature
range?

Comment?

Tom Hendricks

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Challenge - can anyone start life without an energy source?
    ... Can life begin independently from ... > where life was NOT forced into being by an outside energy source? ... Science offers circumstancial evidence, at least, while you offer NONE. ... No doubt you've heard the story about the policeman who found a little boy ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Which Came First
    ... >>> Replication is necessary for any definition of Darwinian life. ... >>> have life without a preexisting energy source. ... > It is not what chemicals get to ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Must have a Cyclical Energy Source to Start Life
    ... I disagree on the oscilatory energy source. ... cannot create life in any test tubes. ... As someone who also thinks that Cairns-Smith is wrong in the final ... and if life requires some kind of genetics, ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Must have a Cyclical Energy Source to Start Life
    ... think that organic chemistry and an aqueous phase are more or less the ... I disagree on the oscilatory energy source. ... cannot create life in any test tubes. ... genetics - hence the key step in the origin of life is the origin of ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Challenge - can anyone start life without an energy source?
    ... Can life begin independently from ... Can anyone suggest an origin scenario ... >> where life was NOT forced into being by an outside energy source? ... Tom's other challenge was to imagine life without water. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)