Re: Non-Coding DNA preserved by genetic drift?




<whitesickle@xxxxxxx> wrote
> "The data suggest it is genetic drift (an evolutionary force whose main
> component is randomness), not natural selection, that preserves junk
> DNA and other extraneous genetic sequences in organisms. When
> population sizes are large, drift is usually overpowered by natural
> selection, but when population sizes are small, drift may actually
> supersede natural selection as the dominant evolutionary force, making
> it possible for weakly disadvantageous DNA sequences to accumulate.
> Junk DNA costs energy to duplicate and to carry around as part of each
> cell. So natural selection operates against it. But if junk DNA gets
> generated by errors in replication faster than natural selection can
> select against it then junk DNA can accumulate."
>
There seems to be a bit of confusion between genetic drift and mutation
pressure.

Genetic drift is caused by chance over- or under- representation of alleles
in the next generation.
Mutation pressure occurs when the chance of A changing to B is greater than
the chance of B changing to A. Eventually B will come to predominate,
assuming no other forces.
This may be happening with junk DNA.



.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Non-Coding DNA preserved by genetic drift?
    ... DNA" is very important and has to be seen as a part of the genetic ... by genetic drift, how if at all does that throw in a monkey wrench to ... For Darwin it was natural selection. ... drift and there is very little "junk DNA". ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Non-Coding DNA preserved by genetic drift?
    ... "Assuming non-coding DNA is preserved ... > by genetic drift, how if at all does that throw in a monkey wrench to ... For Darwin it was natural selection. ... > drift and there is very little "junk DNA". ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Junk Dna!
    ... > Collin DuCrane wrote: ... >> natural selection. ... According to the present model of selection and evolution, "junk ... DNA serves no purpose. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Junk Dna!
    ... bases in every single cell. ... budget of sugars and bases the DNA represents. ... junk may well be something that is selected *for*. ... Now you claim that natural selection is so powerful ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Junk Dna!
    ... natural selection. ... According to the present model of selection and evolution, "junk ... DNA serves no purpose. ... mutating, but the result of that mutation is undetectable, then isn't ...
    (talk.origins)

Loading