Article: Evolution: Looking for an advantage



Nature Reviews Genetics 7, 496 (July 2006) | doi:10.1038/nrg1900

Evolution: Looking for an advantage
Patrick Goymer

Skewed patterns of polymorphism around a locus can imply that it has
recently been subject to selection. Many studies have therefore looked for
evidence of selection in the large sets of polymorphism data that have
recently become available. Teshima et al. have now shown that the
reliability of empirical approaches to assessing such data depends on
demography and the nature and history of the allele being selected.

Polymorphism at neutral sites in the genome is not entirely free from the
influence of selection. A neutral allele at a locus that happens to be close
to an advantageous allele at a locus under selection will 'hitchhike' to
near-fixation along with the selected allele. Therefore, levels of
polymorphism at neutral sites will be reduced if selection has acted nearby.

There are several models of expected neutral polymorphism against which data
can be compared when looking for selection. However, the results are often
sensitive to the assumptions of the model. Therefore, a simple empirical
approach is often used for genome-wide analyses, in which sites with the
most skewed polymorphism patterns are assumed to be those that are linked to
selected sites. But what are false-discovery and false-negative rates in
this approach, and are there systematic biases against discovering certain
types of selected site?

Teshima et al. simulated data sets for the evolution of modern humans and
the domestication of maize. They attempted to make their data realistic by
including bottlenecks (to mimic non-sub-Saharan human populations) or
constant population sizes (for sub-Saharan populations), and strong
selection on previously neutral alleles (for the relatively sudden
artificial selection imposed by man in domesticating maize) compared with
weaker selection on new mutations (for wild plant populations).

Source: Nature Genetics
http://www.nature.com/nrg/journal/v7/n7/full/nrg1900.html

Posted by
Robert Karl Stonjek


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Mutationism Redux
    ... It looks like it is conserving energy to me. ... assumption that natural selection is exerting significant control over ... There are lots of things (balanced polymorphism, ... any situation of balanced polymorphism as being due to the lack ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Cost of sex - a bargain!
    ... Don't-Be-Asexual is not an 'allele' of Be-Asexual at all. ... If asexuals were ... The selection in this case is in the population as a whole, ... variant portion of the population (the sexuals) will undergo selective ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Cost of sex - a bargain!
    ... Don't-Be-Asexual is not an 'allele' of Be-Asexual at all. ... in a functional sexual female. ... Selection is blind to the distinction between sexuals and asexuals. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... >> The argument I am making about the effectiveness of kin selection (the ... >> allele from a gene pool. ... never very great, because close relatives may not contain the allele, while ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Hamiltons rule
    ... Selection is generated by fitness differences, ... >>> strength of selection changes in a sigmoid fashion relative to frequency for ... which simulates changes in allele frequencies ... >> I claim that the trajectory of the altruism trait is sigmoid in almost exactly ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)