Re: Article: Scientists propose the kind of chemistry that led to




"Perplexed in Peoria" <jimmenegay@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
In its simplest form, ... The process could go like this:
Catalyst A produces a chemical that catalyst B uses. Now, since B normally
seeks out this chemical, sometimes B will be attracted to A -- if its
desired chemical is not otherwise available nearby. As a result, A and B
will come into proximity, forming a complex.

Catalyst B normally 'seeks out' its substrate? Wow. That is one smart,
well motivated molecule!

One hopes this was metaphor. But metaphor for what??!!

JE:-
It appears to me to be a metaphor for the evolution of fitness independent
systems. If the two molecles concerned remain in close enough proximity by
chance e.g. within a membrain bound system, and this helps maintain the
complex as a single system for longer then natural selection will select for
it even if the system cannot reproduce itself. In other words survival can
be evelvated to become the fitness maximand of the system (the one thing
which always pertains to a maximum without exception, within each competing
system) in the absence of reproduction. However, once the reproduction of
the entire system becomes a reality the fitness maximand must move from just
survival to the reproduction of each system. The next stage is the
evolution of fitness interdependent systems, i.e. the evolution of
independent but entirely fitness mutualized systems via their continued
association within optimal sized groups. Here each group can act as a
powerful selective force on each individual system (known as the Baldwin
effect) but not as one grouped selectee (a grouped thing being selected) as
was incorrectly assumed by classical group selection.


Regards,

John Edser
Independent Researcher

edser@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The status of Infertile forms ( was: What is the evolutionary
    ... Sometimes infertile offspring do not remain an integrated part of a fertile ... independent fitness must remain zero. ... fitness (especially reproduction) may not be a goal for all ... Why did you exclude selection OF the group in which each group fitness ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: Felsenstein and reproductive excess
    ... > based his cost concept on "genetic death", ... Sub selection is a dependent act of selection, ... sterile immatures to become fitness equivalent to fertile adults they ... and the reproduction rate required to produce it. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: The ultimate cause of aging
    ... survival and reproduction indefinitely. ... Natural selection must act to maximise fitness, ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: The Paradox of Speciation
    ... reproduction. ... incompatibility can't be promoted by selection. ... Selection pressure on the reproductive system itself (i.e. the ... made by that system to the overall fitness of the organism. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Mathematics Is Not a Science
    ... which is the ONLY trait that selection can act on ... > with perfectly additive effects on fitness. ... has ever been documented within nature. ... experiment I proposed to provide a refutation of Darwin's ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)

Loading