Re: Religion

On Aug 3, 8:02 pm, Alexm <amcwill...@xxxxxxx> wrote:
A Martian (if one existed) observing earth could fairly easily
perceive that humans have religions. Are there any other creatures on
earth the behaviors of which can be interpreted as being in some sense
religious in nature?

There are behaviors of animals that have been interpreted as being
homologous to religion. Read "The Ascent of man" by Charles Darwin.
Darwin talks about his dog, growling at a wind chime. He claims that
the confusion of the dog is either homologous or analogous to a human
believing in spirits. A Martian, seeing that dog growl at the wind
chime, could have seen it the same way.
Darwin makes an interesting observation which I am not sure is
true. He claims that most spirits are evil. He attributes that to the
defensive nature of natural selection. Natural selection favors
protective rather than trusting responses.
Dog hears wind chime, dog only has experience with humans who
ring wind chimes, dog concludes that a human is ringing the wind
chime, but an invisible human. One who isn't trying to pet him. It
must be an invisible intruder, the worse type of intruder! So the dog
barks. In actuality, it was only Satan...


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: You MUST KNOW THIS MAN
    ... It is the support of Muslim communities & the ... As with other religions, it ... you be my dog and i will be your tree and you can pee on ... And now I wanna be your dog ...
    (alt.support.chronic-pain)
  • Re: Pit Bull Attack
    ... the possibility their animal nature will overcome the training. ... and the owners of the dog should be held responsible. ... agree that, for the most part, Pit Bulls can be truly dangerous animals, ... and do have a more aggressive nature than most, ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)
  • Re: The dogs dinner...
    ... a cup or 2 of dry dog food and the rest of the time, ... other things in fairly substantial quantity but calls that a 'treat'. ... In nature, a dog would be happy to eat every 2 days. ...
    (rec.food.cooking)
  • Re: Recent digging dog driving us nuts!
    ... >This Border Collie is sensitive by nature -- the most sensitive dog I've ... human-human or your human-dog communication skills, or both, that are ...
    (rec.pets.dogs.behavior)
  • Re: {WR} Dartmoor (RESCUED by AIR AMBULANCE - long)
    ... of nature for you. ... Thank goodness we got her out of the water. ... Last winter there was a similar walk on the north moor in teeming rain, the leader altered the route for the conditions, today it was less easy to do that given where it was. ... The only suggestion I have is to get a bigger dog; one that can jump the streams on his own. ...
    (uk.sci.weather)