Re: Why do we need definitions?

From: Gary Forbis (forbisgaryg_at_msn.com)
Date: 06/25/04


Date: 25 Jun 2004 09:07:57 -0700


"FiSH" <a_fisher@hotmail .com> wrote in message news:<40dbe1e7$1@news1.veridas.net>...
> umm.........why bring freedom into the topic, that was a completely
> subjective move and hardly philosophical.
>
> ostensive definitions are only part of a set of locutionary forces within
> the world and human mind.

You see, this is where I argue against Glen. I would replace "human mind"
with "human brain". Talk about the human mind is completely subjective.

Many have wacked others with sticks in an effort to determine the set of
locutionary forces within the brain that lead to the exclamation, "Ow!
Stop that!" There are some who have coined the abstract term "pain"
in an effort to explain the behavior but we find this "explanation"
lacking in rigor. One might as well be talking about The Gods moving
the Sun and the Moon across the mantle of the sky.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why do we need definitions?
    ... ostensive definitions are only part of a set of locutionary forces within ... the world and human mind. ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: OT: Sam Harris on Francis Collins
    ... "He claims that the human mind cannot be the product of the ... human brain or the human brain the product of unguided evolution: ... mockery of whole fields of study?neuroscience, psychology, cognitive ... must look to religion to explain our moral sense, ...
    (rec.arts.mystery)
  • Re: Tthe New Leader
    ... "self-programming" computers being more intelligent than a human mind. ... How will the original designers program in creativity, ... outguess genuinely smarter-than-human intelligence?" ... The human brain is nothing more nor less than a computer. ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: thoughts on Jesus
    ... human mind is entirely contained in the human brain. ... all of the imaginable concepts have no external source ... or connection. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: thoughts on Jesus
    ... human mind is entirely contained in the human brain. ... Attempts to resolve the human mind remind me of the ongoing attempts ... to resolve abiogenesis - everybody is convinced that they know what ... But that's the difference between science and opinions formed on vague ...
    (talk.origins)