Re: The Identity Theory of Mind

From: Lester Zick (lesterDELzick_at_worldnet.att.net)
Date: 09/24/04 

Date: Fri, 24 Sep 2004 18:38:47 GMT

On 23 Sep 2004 15:17:25 -0700, zzbunker@netscape.net (ZZBunker) in
comp.ai.philosophy wrote:

>lesterDELzick@worldnet.att.net (Lester Zick) wrote in message news:<4151cbee.32163082@netnews.att.net>...
>> On Wed, 22 Sep 2004 11:33:30 -0500, Paul Bramscher
>> <brams006_nospam@tc.umn.edu> in comp.ai.philosophy wrote:
>>
>> >Wolf Kirchmeir wrote:
>> >
>> >> Paul Bramscher wrote:
>> >>
>> >>> The Sophist wrote:
>> >>>
>> >>>> Paul Bramscher wrote:
>> >>>>
>> >>>>> Since most philosophical theories of the mind appear to be
>> >>>>> astoundingly inbred (relatively small number of constantly
>> >>>>> referenced writers, and all Western/white/academic), there are some
>> >>>>> important missing critiques to the identity theory:
>> >>
>> >> [...]
>> >>
>> >>>>
>> >>>>
>> >>>> Apparently you have not actually read extensively from the literature
>> >>>> you denigrate. Certainly Parfit is aware of these issues, and the
>> >>>> Churchlands show more than a bit of sensitivity to them.
>> >>>
>> >>>
>> >>>
>> >>> Literature doesn't solve this problem. One should take a theory and
>> >>> point it toward empirical evidence. Don't just point toward a theory
>> >>> or piece of literature as an ends to itself.
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> Ah, but for philosophers, the literature is the important thing.
>> >
>> >Which is odd, since the great philosophers the followers constantly like
>> >to reference are -- themselves -- the counter-examples! At some point
>> >they left the library, set aside a book, and engineered their own
>> >theories -- for better or worse.
>> >
>> >I'm not anti-literature (in fact I'm currently sitting in a large
>> >research library in North America). It's just that you need to set it
>> >aside at some point and budget your time. I'm more allied to the art of
>> >design & building, rather than deconstructing or analyzing as an ends to
>> >itself. The best sources of my own inspiration are other builders and
>> >engineers, not analysts and intellectual forensics specialists. :-)
>>
>> How does one engineer the right without deconstructing the wrong? Why
>> do you think theories of the mind are so inbred and keep coming up
>> with the same tired nonsense?
>
> It's most likely that Philosophers prefer science-fiction
> to science, and scientists prefer treatises
> on Lepto-Quark positivism to thinking, Politicians
> prefer photo-ops with Bill Gates to engineering,
> and Literaturists prefer 4000 year-old decaying
> religous slums to minds.

There's some truth to this, ZZ. But I'm more inclined to think that
academics, politicians, etc. prefer these kinds of esoteric solutions
because the public prefers them whereas the public is bored silly with
conventional philosophical wisdom because philosophers and politicians
are really just talking heads blowing smoke, either explaining the
obvious ad nauseum or indulging in turgid nonsense.

Regards - Lester

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Identity Theory of Mind
    ... > How does one engineer the right without deconstructing the wrong? ... > do you think theories of the mind are so inbred and keep coming up ... It's most likely that Philosophers prefer science-fiction ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: Tolls
    ... so far as I am concerned all politicians are the ... The very thought of seeking power over your fellow humans should ... The kind of mind that seeks power is exactly the type ... Jury service style politics, six months stint, and only people who have to ...
    (uk.rec.driving)
  • Re: Tolls
    ... so far as I am concerned all politicians are the ... The very thought of seeking power over your fellow humans should ... exactly the type of mind that should never, ... Jury service style politics, six months stint, and only people who ...
    (uk.rec.driving)
  • Re: ot-political-(cant help myself) justice dept/andrew card/gonzalez/ashcroft
    ... us government against it's own citizens that has been found to be ... If you don't mind, I would like to answer this also, because I think I have ... I don't think it's 'OK' for the government to do anything which is illegal, ... The truth is, no matter what politicians do, they can never assure we will ...
    (rec.music.makers.percussion)
  • Re: death of the mind.
    ... Subject: death of the mind. ... >>Best that you had not used the word indoctrination here in the first ... Let's look at the engineer. ... if they understand WHY the formulas specify what they should do in those ...
    (sci.cognitive)