Re: Religion center in the brain


<jalegris@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1157554167.358836.35350@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Glen M. Sizemore wrote:
"Francis Burton" <fburton@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1156956110.585369@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In article <4llpltF2eggvU1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Joachim Pimiskern <JoachimPimiskern@xxxxxx> wrote:
A newer article cast doubt on the discovery:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/5296728.stm?lsf

Oh dear, just because more than one spot lights up there isn't
a "centre"?! Can someone name =any= brain function or activity
that is localized to a single spot? To my mind, it doesn't make
sense to talk about centres for this or that function until we
at least define what we mean by "centre" in this context.

You're right. All this talk about centers is a bunch of horsecrap. It
fits
in nicely with animism, though, and mainstream psychology, and the fields
it
has corrupted, is just a "modern" form of animism.



You're seeing the crap before the horse. Modern neurology got its start
from the apparent connections between specific brain injuries and
associated behavioural changes. Some were borne out, others were not.
So it goes, and now we sharpen the focus.

But in the final analysis, correlations between brain loci and observed
deficits etc. don't explain how neurophysiology mediates behavioral
function. But it seems that it does to a number of people. Neuroimaging has,
for many, become a sort of endpoint. I suggest that this is because their
conceptualization is now, and has always been, a thinly-disguised animism.
They already talk as if indwelling entities - call them homunculi - see
copies of the world, make decisions on that basis, and pull the levers that
make behavior occur. And now they think they know where the little men are
hiding in the brain.



Your Daddy,

Glen






--
Joe Legris



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Religion center in the brain
    ... just because more than one spot lights up there isn't ... is just a "modern" form of animism. ... correlations between brain loci and observed ... of a duty to an organisation or to a state. ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: Religion center in the brain
    ... just because more than one spot lights up there isn't ... is just a "modern" form of animism. ... correlations between brain loci and observed ... kind of run in a parallel processing fashion? ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: Religion center in the brain
    ... Glen M. Sizemore wrote: ... just because more than one spot lights up there isn't ... is just a "modern" form of animism. ... correlations between brain loci and observed ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: Religion center in the brain
    ... just because more than one spot lights up there isn't ... is just a "modern" form of animism. ... correlations between brain loci and observed ... kind of run in a parallel processing fashion? ...
    (sci.cognitive)
  • Re: Religion center in the brain
    ... just because more than one spot lights up there isn't ... that is localized to a single spot? ... is just a "modern" form of animism. ... Modern neurology got its start ...
    (sci.cognitive)