Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot

royls_at_telus.net
Date: 10/29/04


Date: Fri, 29 Oct 2004 21:58:50 GMT

On 28 Oct 2004 10:58:22 GMT, aft627@aol.com (Andy F) wrote:

>Igor wrote:
>
>>Oh no I have to hang my head in shame now. The statement is correct.
>>REAL GPD Growth per capita is mean reverting. It averages 1% - 2% a
>>year. REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. Most time series methods used
>>shows a linear trend. I say most because some older methods can not
>>reject the unit root hypothesis. It is well known that GDP for the US is
>>trend stationary with a break. THE CONFUSION IS THAT TIME SERIES
>>ANALYSIS ALWAYS ANALYZES GDP IN LOGS. THAT MEANS THE TREND IS LINEAR.
>>The statement is correct.
>>
>>Again you are being deceptive and dishonest because you know this is the
>>case. Any economist reading that statement knows it too.
>>
>So when you said
>
>"There is a limit interest compounds exponentially while GDP grows in a linear
>fashion."
>
>what you really meant was
>
>"interest compounds exponentially while GDP grows in a linear fashion on a
>logarithmic scale"
>
>If you put the compounding interest on a log scale, wouldn't that also be
>linear?

Don't look at the man behind the curtain!

-- Roy L



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot
    ... REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. ... Most time series methods used ... >trend stationary with a break. ... THAT MEANS THE TREND IS LINEAR. ...
    (sci.econ)
  • Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot
    ... REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. ... THE CONFUSION IS THAT TIME SERIES ... THAT MEANS THE TREND IS LINEAR. ... If you engage Igor, you're find yourself thinking, "well, if I'm charitable, ...
    (sci.econ)
  • Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot
    ... REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. ... THE CONFUSION IS THAT TIME SERIES ... I did not insult you though. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot
    ... REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. ... THE CONFUSION IS THAT TIME SERIES ... I did not insult you though. ...
    (sci.econ)
  • Re: Edward Prescott, Idiot
    ... REAL GDP GROWTH IS MEAN REVERTING. ... Most time series methods used ... shows a linear trend. ... trend stationary with a break. ...
    (sci.econ)