Re: how to compare living standards


"William F Hummel" <wfhummel@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:77cu02lssulep8njnqlk74itcb0gg3mh3o@xxxxxxxxxx
On Wed, 8 Mar 2006 12:48:23 -0600, "Jim Blair" <jeb@xxxxxxxx> wrote:

......

And "privatizing Social Security" is a mis-nomer. The question is how
the
retirement of Americans should be funded in the future. And the choices
are
A-"by a wage tax on US workers", or B-"by the growrth of the Global
economy".

Jim, you are conflating financial savings and real savings.

Hi,

Aren't stocks and bonds "real"? Or are they just "financial"?

If the X corporation is "real", why would its stock not be?

....It is
easy to devise a system of retirement savings in terms of financial
wealth for everyone. But individuals need to save for retirement in
the equivalent of real wealth.

Is money saved/invested in an IRA "equivalent to real wealth"?

....Saving dollars or other purely
financial assets doesn't help for retirement if real economic growth
is not commensurate with the growth of the retired population.

I agree that an IRA will not be much good as a source of retirement income
if the companies in the mutual fund don't pay dividends and don't have their
stock prices appreciate.

But this is not a question of "how certain is the future of the Global
economy?". It is a matter of comparison. Which has the better prospects
for the future: A or B?
And I say the global economy is a better base for retirement income than the
wage base of American workers. That given the demographics of the US and
the world populations.

And all of this is not the *real* question anyway, since Americans are now,
and will continue to, use income from both A and B for their retirement.
But now those who pay income taxes can (and do) deduct retirement money from
their IRS taxes. So why not let them also deduct money saved for retirement
from that OTHER income tax that applies to wages only, and which collects
relatively more from the lower incomes?

I say give low income workers the same tax break that the higher income
people now have.



,,,,,,,
_______________ooo___(_O O_)___ooo_______________
(_)
jim blair (jeblair@xxxxxxxx) Madison Wisconsin USA.
This message was brought to you using biodegradable
binary bits, and 100% recycled bandwidth. For a good
time call: http://www.geocities.com/capitolhill/4834


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: OT - Thank you suckers
    ... Q. Should I count on Social Security for all my retirement income? ... Security, 2) pensions, and 3) savings. ...
    (alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers)
  • Re: India could yet play the China hand
    ... dependent on America buying the WalMart trash that all America has to ... China's economy is smaller than was thought ... This is not to deny that income inequality is rising: ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: We Have Chosen?
    ... so, like those 47 million people without health insurance, primarily ... Wealth Inequality Destroys US Ideals ... the U.S. economy saw its second steepest decline in 27 ... income, while the top ten percent took half of the total income, the ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: Think of the people running this country as the mad-dashers
    ... they have access to good jobs at good wages. ... My colleague at The Times, David Cay Johnston, took a look at income ... How the Wealthiest Americans Enrich Themselves at Government ... From 1980 to 2005 the national economy, adjusted for inflation, more ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • NBC: Economy Always in Crisis in Election Years; by George Will
    ... Economy Always in 'Crisis' in Election Years ... Declines in housing values and the stock market are causing some ... Americans to delay retirement. ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)