Re: Henry George: Plagiarist

w_b_ryan@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
"On fiscal matters, the Physiocrats famously pushed
for their 'single tax' on landed property -- l'impôt
unique. The logic, as laid out by Mirabeau (1760)
seemed compelling. Any taxes levied throughout
the economy will just passed from sector to sector
until they fall upon the net product. As land is the
only source of wealth, then the burden of all taxes
ultimately bears down on the landowner. So instead
of levying a complicated collection of scattered
taxes (which are difficult to administer and can
cause temporary distortions), it is most efficient to
just go to the root and tax land rents directly."


From the first chapter of George's 'Progress and Poverty" (looks like he gave credit to Mirabeau in the first sentence of his book):

"CHAPTER I

OF THE EFFECT UPON THE PRODUCTION OF WEALTH

The elder MIRABEAU, we are told, ranked the proposition of Quesnay, to substitute one single tax on rent (the impôt unique) for all other taxes, as a discovery equal in utility to the invention of writing or the substitution of the use of money for barter.
To whosoever will think over the matter, this saying will appear an evidence of penetration rather than of extravagance. The advantages which would be gained by substituting for the numerous taxes by which the public revenues are now raised, a single tax levied upon the value of land, will appear more and more important the more they are considered. This is the secret which would transform the little village into the great city. With all the burdens removed which now oppress industry and hamper exchange, the production of wealth would go on with a rapidity now undreamed of. This, in its turn, would lead to an increase in the value of land—a new surplus which society might take for general purposes. And released from the difficulties which attend the collection of revenue in a way that begets corruption and renders legislation the tool of special interests, society could assume functions which the increasing complexity of life makes it desirable to assume, but which the prospect of political demoralization under the present system now leads thoughtful men to shrink from.

Consider the effect upon the production of wealth.
To abolish the taxation which, acting and reacting, now hampers every wheel of exchange and presses upon every form of industry, would be like removing an immense weight from a powerful spring. Imbued with fresh energy, production would start into new life, and trade would receive a stimulus which would be felt to the remotest arteries. The present method of taxation operates upon exchange like artificial deserts and mountains; it costs more to get goods through a custom house than it does to carry them around the world. It operates upon energy, and industry, and skill, and thrift, like a fine upon those qualities. If I have worked harder and built myself a good house while you have been contented to live in a hovel, the taxgatherer now comes annually to make me pay a penalty for my energy and industry, by taxing me more than you. If I have saved while you wasted, I am mulct, while you are exempt. If a man build a ship we make him pay for his temerity, as though he had done an injury to the state; if a railroad be opened, down comes the tax collector upon it, as though it were a public nuisance; if a manufactory be erected we levy upon it an annual sum which would go far toward making a handsome profit. We say we want capital, but if any one accumulate it, or bring it among us, we charge him for it as though we were giving him a privilege. We punish with a tax the man who covers barren fields with ripening grain, we fine him who puts up machinery, and him who drains a swamp. How heavily these taxes burden production only those realize who have attempted to follow our system of taxation through its ramifications, for, as I have before said, the heaviest part of taxation is that which falls in increased prices. But manifestly these taxes are in their nature akin to the Egyptian Pasha's tax upon date trees. If they do not cause the trees to be cut down, they at least discourage the planting.

To abolish these taxes would be to lift the whole enormous weight of taxation from productive industry. The needle of the seamstress and the great manufactory; the cart horse and the locomotive; the fishing boat and the steamship; the farmer's plow and the merchant's stock, would be alike untaxed. All would be free to make or to save, to buy or to sell, unfined by taxes, unannoyed by the taxgatherer. Instead of saying to the producer, as it does now, "The more you add to the general wealth the more shall you be taxed!" the state would say to the producer, "Be as industrious, as thrifty, as enterprising as you choose, you shall have your full reward! You shall not be fined for making two blades of grass grow where one grew before; you shall not be taxed for adding to the aggregate wealth."
"
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Fed. Gov. Slaps a 53% Tax increase on Cigars & Pipe Tobaccos
    ... Each state has its own taxes for tobacco. ... From one day to another the boat construction industry was ... Wouldn't a tax cut for the low and middle-income tax ...
    (alt.smokers.cigars)
  • Re: Another GOP Idea: The Value-Added Tax
    ... >> with a VAT tax, ... >> I understand that there are millions of taxes out there, ... of production through lower rates of return to those factors. ... The burden of a sales tax on comsumers is obvious --- they get a receipt ...
    (sci.econ)
  • Re: The Fair Tax
    ... Repeal the income tax, corporate taxes, payroll taxes such ... Run the country on a retail sales tax. ... speculation is that we get our software industry back, ...
    (misc.news.internet.discuss)
  • Re: The Fair Tax
    ... Repeal the income tax, corporate taxes, payroll taxes such ... Run the country on a retail sales tax. ... speculation is that we get our software industry back, ... As I understand it, I would have to pay a 23% tax on bread, ...
    (misc.news.internet.discuss)
  • Re: Questions on slightly raising sales tax during a recession/recovery
    ... And this is the point I wish to make regarding "taxes" if the tax ... result than if the tax proceeds are used to provide medical insurance ... won't harm production and you won't harm the economy. ...
    (sci.econ)