Re: Distributed capacitance effects inductor Q?




"Bill Bowden" <wrongaddress@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1177821718.856885.82580@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Does anyone know why the distributed winding capacitance of a loop
antenna, or any inductor, degrades the efficiency?

It would seem that a loop antenna with 100pF of winding capacitance in
parallel with a external capacitor of 200pF would resonate at the
same frequency as a antenna with no winding capacitance and a external
capacitor of 300pF, and perform just as well, but apparently that's
not the case.

The best explanation I got was that winding capacitance represents
'Low Q' and a external tuning capacitor represents 'High Q'

What is the difference between high and low Q, and why should a loop
antenna with no winding capacitance perform any better than one with
50% of the total capacitance in the windings? Where is the energy
loss?

Thanks,

-Bill

I've never noticed it.
As the Q meter was on the bench I tested an AM ferrite radio coil. Value
measured beforehand on two LC meters as 480uH, (one at 1000Hz to preclude
self capacitance issues). (wire was Cotton covered, Litz style, 3 stranded).
600pF 300kHz Q=110
200pF 559kHz Q=140
100pF 800kHz Q=160
70pF 900kHz Q=200
30pF 1350kHz Q=220
10pF 2200kHz Q=200
I didn't extract out the self capacitance but would have thought the
measured Q values would degrade pro rata with reducing external
capacitances.





--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Distributed capacitance effects Q?
    ... antenna, or any inductor, degrades the efficiency? ... same frequency as a antenna with no winding capacitance and a external ... Some thoughts about inductor loss and self capacitance: ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Distributed capacitance effects Q?
    ... same frequency as a antenna with no winding capacitance and a external ... What is the difference between high and low Q, and why should a loop ... I assume that you mean radiation efficiency (ratio between actual ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Distributed capacitance effects inductor Q?
    ... antenna, or any inductor, degrades the efficiency? ... It would seem that a loop antenna with 100pF of winding capacitance in ... same frequency as a antenna with no winding capacitance and a external ...
    (sci.electronics.basics)
  • Re: Trying to model loop antenna (why does capacitance go down when adding parallel cap?)
    ... > My goal is to be able to model the antenna accurately. ... > capacitance needed to get the thing to resonate at 60 khz. ... resonance should occur when the two impedances equal one ... No, for the same reason. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: HIGH Q CAPS FOR VLF LOOP ANTENNA?
    ... > some antenna plans and need .2 uf total capacitance to resonate a loop ... > Any suggestions for 50,000 pF caps that don't cost a fortune? ... And they're available in high capacitance ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)