Re: just had to try this one more time

Reg Edwards wrote:

> Roger, a very nice musical story from a music lover.

That was the short version, here is a longer version in two messages,
quoted from googlegroups, wrote them years ago:
....

I tried to learn to play the guitar when I was young, but I used the
same method you are trying to use, and it didn't work very well.

Later in life I found another way to learn and that worked much better.
I can tell you how.

Put your favorite music on your stereo and play along, and make sure
the volume of your instrument is just as loud as the music.

Try all tones, play very fast so you have time to try many tones.
Fake it, pretend you know how to play, and push whatever keys you like.
You will hear that some tones sound false, others sound in harmony with
the music.
Play the same song over and over again, hundreds of times, and you will
soon learn what tones fit in and which don't.

Note the pattern of the tones that fit in, they form a scale.
Some tones fit in even better and more often than the others at each
moment in the song. They are the chord tones.

Start improvising along with the music, move from one chord tone to
another with the help of the scale tones, and sometimes a halftone fits
in too in a transition between two chords.

Soon you will feel secure enough to play along with that song without
having to think about scales and chords.

Then take another song and do the same with that.

That is the really useful way to learn to play, and you'll learn to
improvise as much as you like too.

The trick is in not being afraid of playing wrong, in fact, the more
you try to do wrong on purpose the more you learn about what
tones fit in and not.
And play fast, try many tones, that will both help you get fast fingers
and let you find the scales and chords you need to know by heart, not
learned from a book.

Turn the lights in the room down low, so you learn to play without
seeing what you are doing, that will help you one day when the lights
go out on stage and other musicians panic. It won't bother you,
because you learned to play in the dark.

Other musicians will panic when then have no sheet music or chords. You
don't care, you have learned to find out the chords and scales very
fast all by yourself and can do it in split seconds while you hear a
new song.

And for Gods sake, use headphones, don't torture your neighbors with
all the noise you are going to produce the first year.
You may need a mixer to mix the music and your instrument into the same
stereo sound picture. Most computer sound cards have such a mixer.

By the way, music is just noise with some structure, some rythm
structure and/or some harmonic structure.
Start by making pure noise, and add some structure here and there.
Don't be afraid of making noise and you will learn how to make music.

After you have learned to play in this way, read some books about
chords
and scales, that will confirm a lot of what you have discovered by
yourself, and give you some new ideas too.


--
Roger J.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Blues that is blues
    ... The blues is an integral part of the culture in Mississippi. ... people play the blues as part of just hanging out. ... More contemporary music seeems to me to be just playing scales ... accentuated by chords. ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: Blues that is blues
    ... The blues is an integral part of the culture in Mississippi. ... people play the blues as part of just hanging out. ... More contemporary music seeems to me to be just playing scales ... accentuated by chords. ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: New player help
    ... Thanks for the advice for chords versus scales. ... I know that you can actually play songs just by ...
    (alt.guitar.beginner)
  • Re: A must See
    ... So those who are trying to work out a philosophical approach to music and the guitar--while they are learning to play by ear--are still left in the dark. ... After learning 12 or 15 chords I more or less plunked around trying to figure out melodies and licks an never really considered their relationship to a chord. ... My chordal conception was almost wholly absent for years. ... Then I learned scales in every conceivable fashion and played them on top of changes, using them as a reference to play lines. ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.jazz)
  • Re: Playing around the chord
    ... long time rock player so I mostly use various scales when soloing. ... in the key that the song is in. ... I play it the same as others even then. ... Most my stuff is based on some chords like some 7's or whatever, ...
    (alt.guitar)