Re: another dead HD, which do you use?



martin griffith wrote:

> 2 HD's dead this month, googleling for "Hard Drive Reliabilty" gives
> zillions of pages of adverts saying how reliable Our HD's are. Even
> tomshardware didnt go into it in detail
>
> What do you use?
>
> BTW I notice that my latest drive must not be exposed to more than
> 350G's of shock. I'd accept 100G's if they lasted longer...

My experience of the former Quantum drives as system disks was exemplary.
I don't recall one of their SCSI drives ever giving problems and I only
once had a problem with one IDE drive of their manufacture - long, long
after purchase btw - and it was recoverable enough to make a perfect
backup.

No other brand of drive ever came close. Note that IBM, Apple and I think
maybe HP and Compaq have all used Quantum drives.

They got bought by Maxtor. I hear mixed opinions about them now.

I thought I was buying quality with IBM deskstars for a Raid mirror.
Although they aren't from the series that have the 'click of death'
syndrome - one drive irregularly seems to fail to unlock its heads ( as
it seems ) and I get a broken mirror message. Restarting the PC always
fixes it. I don't like using a questionable drive - but I don't think I'm
going to get it replaced under these circumstances. There is of course
always the mirror itself to fall back on luckily !

Graham

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: another dead HD, which do you use?
    ... > 2 HD's dead this month, googleling for "Hard Drive Reliabilty" gives ... To make sure my hd's are dead, I usually use a 1/4" carbide-tipped ... Disk drives are like tires (or tyres, depending on which side of the ... platter at work to which has been affixed a clock movement. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: another dead HD, which do you use?
    ... googleling for "Hard Drive Reliabilty" gives ... other live drives I have, even the oldest, the IBM 28gig). ... the CRT monitor causing it. ... moving a magnet anywhere along the case. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: another dead HD, which do you use?
    ... googleling for "Hard Drive Reliabilty" gives ... >zillions of pages of adverts saying how reliable Our HD's are. ... >tomshardware didnt go into it in detail ... Samsung drives are supposed to be the good ones. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Worst monday of my life - please help...
    ... If that's the case, restoring the SQL ... but it finally did install with a few hiccups. ... >> or just leave the mirrored drives in the server on the secondary IDE ... I decided it was time to re-add the mirror. ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.sbs)
  • Re: Realistic drive arrays
    ... > may be an opportunity to swap 2 of the disks for a pair of 143Gb drives ... >> two drives in the same mirror failing within the parts replacement SLA of ... >> How much memory the store.exe process uses really depends on how much ... >>> copy of the database on the disk. ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.setup)

Loading