Re: the best Active *Noise* Reduction technology existing



mamadu@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Hi,

I am trying to decide on an Active Noise Reduction (ANR) headset or
earplugs. I have looked at the Sony, Bose, Shure and other models, but
almost all reviews/comments mix two very different issues: noise
reduction and sound quality.

In my case, I have no interest whatsoever in sound quality, what I am
looking for is the absolute best noise reduction possible. I have
tried the Bose Quiet Comfort II, and they appear extremeny effective,
but only in the middle-low frequency range. Also, I have a feeling
that ANR earplugs might be more effective.

Various manufacters claims various degrees of noise reduction. As for
Bose, they do not even release their technical specs (although would it
not be possible for any lab to measure them across a frequency range
and publish the results?).

Recently I met a guy who was working in the US Navy on the deck of
aircraft carriers. He said that the headsets they had cancelled out
everything, that nothing could be heared at all when he was wearing
them. Since this hardly constitutes a secret technology, is it known
who designs these headsets for the US Navy? Is this technology used
for the civilian market by some manufacturer?

Can anyone give me some pointers as to how I could go about finding the
best ANR headset/earbuds out there?


Depending on what you try to attenuate, they may not
work as desired. While they are able to attenuate the
lower frequencies, they produce higher frequencies
that are making you more tired.
In smaller airplanes I feel better with switching
the active compensation off.

Rene
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: ANR headset - which one??
    ... The Bose headsets become less than worthless if the ANR dies. ... They also sell an adapter thatll power them ...
    (rec.aviation.rotorcraft)
  • Re: Bose Aviation-X Headset Update
    ... IMO, it's not just the ANR capabilities of the Bose, it is also the ... But I certainly agree that one man's comfort is another man's ... trip across the US, and I am still very happy with the headsets. ...
    (rec.aviation.piloting)
  • Re: the best Active *Noise* Reduction technology existing
    ... Noise Reduction Rating of 32 decibels. ... tried the Bose Quiet Comfort II, and they appear extremeny effective, ... My feeling is the Sennheiser pilot headsets are definitely better in an open ...
    (rec.travel.air)
  • Re: Deedback Wanted: ANR Headset
    ... Zuvor hatte ich ein ... Mit dem Bose bin ich nun 250 h geflogen, 50% auf einer lauten C 182 ... Aber die ANR wirkt ja gerade im niederfrequenten Bereich ... besonders gut - und da sind passive Headsets dann klar unterlegen. ...
    (de.rec.luftfahrt)
  • Re: Bose Headsets
    ... fantasized about a ANR headset but am deterred by the money. ... I'll say the same thing about ANR headsets - if being able to hear as ... set of headsets that protects your hearing as well as you can, ... ear-damaging frequencies than ordinary noise attenuating headsets? ...
    (rec.aviation.owning)